The Controversial History of Brominated Vegetable Oil (BVO)
Brominated vegetable oil (BVO) is a modified vegetable oil used in beverages since the 1920s. Its purpose was to prevent oil-based flavorings from separating from water in drinks, ensuring a consistent mixture and cloudy look. It was widely used in citrus drinks like Mountain Dew.
Why BVO Was Considered a Risk
BVO was initially deemed 'generally recognized as safe' (GRAS) but was reclassified in 1970 due to animal study concerns. It was allowed on an 'interim' basis in limited amounts, but health concerns persisted. Animal studies indicated BVO led to bromine accumulation in fatty tissues and organs. While human effects were unclear, high bromine levels (bromism) can cause neurological issues. A 2022 study highlighted the thyroid as a target organ for adverse effects.
The Industry Responds and the Global Ban
Facing pressure and new data, beverage companies began removing BVO. PepsiCo announced its removal from products like Mountain Dew in 2014, with the ingredient officially phased out later. Other companies, including Coca-Cola, also removed BVO. Many countries had already banned BVO, including the UK (1970), EU (2008), and Japan (2010). Canada also banned BVO in 2024.
Comparison of BVO-Containing vs. BVO-Free Beverages
| Feature | BVO-Containing Beverage (Before 2016) | BVO-Free Beverage (Modern) | 
|---|---|---|
| Emulsifier | Brominated Vegetable Oil (BVO) | Sucrose Acetate Isobutyrate (SAIB), Ester Gum, or other alternatives | 
| Appearance | Cloudy and consistent due to BVO's density-adjusting properties | Maintained stability through alternative emulsifiers; appearance is often indistinguishable from older versions | 
| Health Concerns | Linked to bromine accumulation in fatty tissues, potential thyroid issues, and neurological effects | No BVO-related health concerns; modern alternatives are deemed safer by regulatory bodies | 
| Market Availability | No longer legally available in the U.S. or many other countries as of 2024/2025 | Widespread availability in compliance with current regulations | 
| Flavor | Some consumers report a difference in taste, attributing it to the presence of BVO | The flavor is maintained through reformulated recipes and ingredient alternatives | 
The Final U.S. Ban
The U.S. FDA finalized a ban on BVO in July 2024, effective August 2024, citing new scientific evidence that it's not safe. Manufacturers have one year to comply. This action completes its global ban journey, though older products may still be available temporarily.
Conclusion: Looking Beyond BVO
The removal of BVO from drinks like Mountain Dew highlights the need for continuous assessment of food ingredients. BVO was used for a cosmetic effect potentially at the expense of health. Safer alternatives now achieve the same result. The BVO ban underscores the importance of transparency in food production. Consumers can make informed choices by reading labels. For more on food additives and chemical safety, resources like the Environmental Working Group (EWG) are helpful.