Decoding Canned Tuna: Beyond the Label
Canned tuna is a pantry staple, celebrated for its convenience, affordability, and nutritional value. It’s an excellent source of lean protein, B vitamins, and minerals like selenium. However, navigating the many options can be confusing. To make an informed, healthy choice, you must look beyond basic labels like “chunk” or “solid” and consider the species of tuna, how it's packed, and fishing practices.
Species Showdown: Light vs. White Tuna
When you’re standing in the canned seafood aisle, the primary health consideration is the type of tuna species inside. The two most common types are 'white' and 'light.'
Mercury Concerns and Species Size
One of the most significant factors separating these options is their mercury content. Tuna, like other fish, can accumulate methylmercury from the water. Larger, longer-living species of tuna accumulate more mercury throughout their lifespan.
-
Light Tuna (Skipjack and sometimes Yellowfin): This variety is made from smaller species like skipjack and younger yellowfin tuna. Because they are smaller and have a shorter lifespan, they naturally have the lowest mercury levels. The FDA recommends that sensitive groups, including pregnant women, breastfeeding women, and young children, opt for this "Best Choice".
-
White Tuna (Albacore): Albacore is a larger species of tuna than skipjack and therefore contains higher levels of mercury. The FDA places it in the "Good Choices" category, recommending that adults limit consumption to one 4-ounce serving per week.
-
Bigeye Tuna: Often used in sushi, Bigeye tuna is the largest and highest in mercury and should be avoided by all sensitive populations. It is rarely sold canned.
Packing Liquid: Oil or Water?
The liquid tuna is packed in affects its nutritional profile, particularly its calorie and fat content. The choice depends on your dietary goals.
-
Tuna Packed in Water: This option is the lowest in calories and fat, which is beneficial for those watching their weight. It retains more of the tuna's natural flavor and may also retain more of the beneficial DHA omega-3 fatty acids.
-
Tuna Packed in Oil: Tuna packed in oil, typically vegetable or olive oil, has a richer flavor and texture. However, it is significantly higher in calories and fat. While some of the omega-3s may transfer to the oil, the added fat can be substantial. For a heart-healthy boost, choosing extra virgin olive oil-packed varieties can add monounsaturated fats, but rinsing or draining the oil is recommended to reduce calories.
Nutritional Comparison: Water-Packed Tuna (3 oz serving)
| Nutrient | White Albacore | Light Skipjack |
|---|---|---|
| Protein | 20 g | 17 g |
| Fat | 2.5 g | 0.8 g |
| Omega-3s | 0.7 g | 0.2 g |
| Calories | ~100 | ~70 |
Sustainability and Fishing Methods
For the environmentally conscious consumer, how tuna is caught is a critical health consideration for the planet. Not all fishing methods are equal in their impact on marine ecosystems.
-
Pole-and-Line or Troll-Caught: This is considered the most sustainable fishing method. Each fish is caught individually, minimizing the accidental catch of other marine life (bycatch) like dolphins, turtles, and sharks. Look for labels indicating “pole-and-line caught” to support these practices and help reduce the environmental impact of your food.
-
FAD-Free Purse Seine: Large nets called purse seines are used to encircle schools of tuna. When used without Fish Aggregating Devices (FADs), which attract many non-target species, it is a more sustainable option than purse seining with FADs.
-
Longline Fishing: This method uses a single long line with thousands of baited hooks. It is known to have high rates of bycatch and is considered a less sustainable practice.
Can Linings and Additives
Bisphenol A (BPA)
Historically, many cans were lined with a resin containing BPA, a chemical with potential health concerns. While most manufacturers have moved to alternative linings, some tests have still detected BPA in canned goods, even those labeled "BPA-free". Pouches are a potential way to reduce exposure, but for canned options, opting for BPA-free labeled cans from reputable brands is recommended.
Sodium
Canned tuna can contain high levels of sodium. For those on a salt-restricted diet, it's wise to look for varieties labeled "low sodium" or "no salt added".
Conclusion: Making the Healthiest Choice
The healthiest canned tuna for you depends on your individual health concerns and dietary priorities. For the lowest mercury and safest option for sensitive populations, canned light tuna packed in water is the clear winner. For those prioritizing higher omega-3 intake and not concerned with mercury levels, albacore is an option, though it should be consumed less frequently. Regardless of species, choosing sustainable options like "pole-and-line caught" benefits marine ecosystems by reducing bycatch. Finally, for peace of mind regarding chemical exposure, seeking out BPA-free packaging or pouches is a worthwhile consideration. By considering all these factors, you can confidently select the best canned tuna to support your personal nutrition diet and environmental values.
To learn more about seafood sustainability, check out the Marine Stewardship Council.
