Understanding Raw Milk Cheese
Raw milk cheese, also known as unpasteurized cheese, is crafted from milk that has not undergone the pasteurization process. Pasteurization is the process of heating milk to a specific temperature for a set period to kill potentially harmful bacteria, such as Listeria, Salmonella, and E. coli. For cheesemakers, using raw milk is often a way to preserve the unique microbial flora of the milk, which can contribute to more complex and distinct flavors in the finished product.
However, due to the risk of foodborne illnesses, the production and sale of raw milk cheese are strictly regulated in many parts of the world. In the United States, for instance, federal law prohibits the interstate sale of any cheese made from unpasteurized milk unless it has been aged for a minimum of 60 days. This aging period, combined with the natural acidity and salt content of the cheese, creates an environment where most dangerous bacteria cannot survive. The regulations for raw milk cheese vary in other countries, with some nations having different standards or no restrictions at all.
Popular Unpasteurized Cheeses
Many of the world's most renowned cheeses are traditionally made with raw milk. These varieties often benefit from the complex flavors that raw milk's natural enzymes and bacteria provide. When shopping, it's always wise to check the label or ask your cheesemonger, as some brands produce both pasteurized and unpasteurized versions to cater to different markets.
Hard and Semi-Hard Cheeses
- Parmigiano-Reggiano: This famous Italian hard cheese is a prime example, with Italian law mandating the use of unpasteurized milk for its production. It is aged for at least 12 months, and often longer, developing its characteristic nutty and savory flavor.
- Gruyère: A classic Swiss alpine cheese, Gruyère is traditionally made with raw cow's milk and aged for many months in caves, which is crucial to its flavor profile.
- Comte: From the Jura Massif region of France, Comté is made with raw milk and aged for a minimum of 4 months, though some are aged for 24 months or more.
- Aged Cheddar: While many commercial cheddars are pasteurized, high-quality, artisanal cheddars like Westcombe and Hafod are often made with raw milk and aged for significant periods.
Blue and Semi-Soft Cheeses
- Roquefort: One of France's most iconic blue cheeses, Roquefort is made exclusively from unpasteurized sheep's milk.
- Morbier: This French semi-soft cheese, known for its distinctive layer of ash, is also traditionally made with raw milk.
- Brie de Meaux: A classic Brie variety from France, this soft cheese is traditionally unpasteurized. Many Brie cheeses available commercially are pasteurized, so seeking out the authentic AOC version is key.
- Raclette: Both Swiss and French varieties of this meltable cheese are commonly made with unpasteurized milk.
Comparison: Raw vs. Pasteurized Cheeses
| Feature | Raw Milk Cheeses | Pasteurized Milk Cheeses | 
|---|---|---|
| Flavor Complexity | Often more complex, nuanced, and richer due to natural milk enzymes and bacteria. | Generally milder, with a more consistent and predictable flavor profile. | 
| Food Safety | Low risk for aged varieties (60+ days) due to aging process; higher risk for young or fresh varieties. | Very low risk of harmful bacteria due to heat treatment during production. | 
| Texture | Can exhibit a broader range of textures, with unique characteristics influenced by the raw milk's composition. | Tends to have a more uniform and consistent texture across batches. | 
| Legality | Heavily regulated in many countries; must be aged a minimum of 60 days for sale in the U.S.. | Few restrictions, widely available and suitable for all consumers. | 
| Target Consumer | Cheese connoisseurs, gastronomes, and those seeking authentic, traditional flavors. | General consumers, pregnant women, children, and immunocompromised individuals. | 
Important Considerations for Consumption
While aged raw milk cheeses are generally considered safe for most people, certain demographics should exercise caution. Pregnant women, the elderly, young children, and individuals with compromised immune systems are advised by health organizations like the CDC and FDA to avoid all raw milk products, including aged cheese. This is because even with aging, there is a small, residual risk of pathogenic bacteria that could be especially dangerous for these vulnerable groups.
For those who prefer not to consume raw milk products, excellent pasteurized alternatives exist for nearly every type of cheese. It is also important to note that cooking raw milk cheese (such as in a fondue or baked dish) to a high enough internal temperature will effectively kill any harmful bacteria. Always read labels carefully and, when in doubt, speak to a knowledgeable cheesemonger about the origin and production methods of the cheese.
Conclusion
The world of cheese offers a diverse palette of flavors, and unpasteurized varieties play a significant role in this culinary landscape. From the nutty, crystalline texture of Parmigiano-Reggiano to the pungent bite of Roquefort, these cheeses are valued for their traditional methods and complex taste. By understanding the aging requirements and safety considerations, particularly for sensitive individuals, consumers can confidently explore the rich traditions of raw milk cheesemaking. While pasteurized options provide a consistently safe choice for all, the unique characteristics of unpasteurized cheeses continue to be cherished by many. For further information on the specific regulations governing raw milk products, consult the FDA's official guidance.