Skip to content

What Makes Wine Hangovers Worse? The Science Behind the Suffering

4 min read

While all alcohol can cause a hangover, some research suggests that drinks with higher levels of congeners, like red wine, can lead to more severe symptoms. A combination of specific compounds and physiological effects are what makes wine hangovers worse for many people.

Quick Summary

Specific compounds like congeners, histamines, and tannins in certain wines can intensify hangover symptoms. Factors like dehydration, sugar content, and an individual's sensitivity also contribute to a worse experience.

Key Points

  • Congeners are key culprits: Darker wines, like reds, contain higher levels of congeners—chemical byproducts of fermentation that worsen hangovers.

  • Histamines trigger headaches: Red wine often contains higher levels of histamines, which can cause blood vessel dilation and headaches in sensitive individuals.

  • Tannins may cause migraines: Found in grape skins, tannins in red wine are believed to trigger headaches in some people by affecting serotonin levels.

  • Dehydration is a major factor: Like all alcohol, wine acts as a diuretic, leading to dehydration which exacerbates common hangover symptoms like headaches and fatigue.

  • Individual sensitivity matters: A person's genetics and metabolism can play a significant role in how severely they react to compounds like histamines and alcohol byproducts.

  • Preventative measures are effective: Pacing your drinks, staying hydrated with water, and eating before drinking can significantly reduce the risk and severity of a wine hangover.

In This Article

The Culprits in Your Glass: Compounds That Intensify Hangovers

While the ethanol in any alcoholic beverage is the primary cause of a hangover, the additional compounds found in different drinks can significantly increase the severity of your next-day misery. When it comes to wine, especially certain types, a cocktail of fermentation byproducts and other substances can make the experience particularly punishing. Understanding these factors is key to preventing that dreaded wine hangover.

Congeners: The Darker the Drink, the Worse the Morning

Congeners are chemical byproducts of the fermentation process that give alcoholic beverages their distinct flavor, aroma, and color. Studies have shown a strong link between higher congener levels and more severe hangovers. This is because your body has to work harder to break down both the ethanol and these extra compounds. Red wines and darker liquors like brandy and whiskey contain higher concentrations of congeners than their lighter counterparts, such as white wine, vodka, or gin. A specific congener, acetaldehyde, is particularly toxic and is also produced as your body metabolizes ethanol, worsening hangover symptoms like inflammation.

Histamines and Tyramine: Triggering Headaches

Wine, particularly red wine, can contain biogenic amines like histamines and tyramine. For individuals with a sensitivity to these compounds, they can be a major source of a severe hangover headache. Histamine is naturally present in wines that have undergone malolactic fermentation, a process more common in red wines, and can cause allergic reactions, flushed skin, and headaches by dilating blood vessels. Tyramine, also found in aged and fermented foods, can trigger migraine headaches in susceptible individuals. Some people are also deficient in the enzyme (DAO) needed to break down these amines, which makes them more vulnerable to these effects.

The Influence of Tannins and Sulfites

Tannins are phenolic compounds found in grape skins, seeds, and stems, contributing to a wine's astringency and complexity. In red wine, tannins have been suggested to affect serotonin levels and trigger headaches in some people, similar to the effects seen with dark chocolate or tea. While often blamed for hangovers, sulfites—preservatives added to wine—are less likely to be the main cause. Most people are not sensitive to sulfites, and their concentration in wine is typically much lower than in many processed foods. For the small percentage of the population with a genuine sulfite sensitivity (often asthmatics), symptoms are more like breathing difficulties than headaches.

Dehydration and Sugar: Exacerbating the Problem

Like all alcoholic beverages, wine is a diuretic, meaning it increases urination and leads to dehydration. Dehydration is a key factor in most hangover symptoms, including headaches, thirst, and fatigue. The sugar content in wine, particularly in sweeter varieties, can also contribute to a more pronounced hangover. High sugar intake can cause a spike and then a crash in blood sugar levels, which can intensify feelings of dizziness and fatigue.

A Comparison of Hangover Factors in Different Beverages

Factor Red Wine White Wine Clear Spirits (Vodka)
Congeners High Low Very Low
Histamines High Low None
Tannins High Very Low None
Sulfites Lower on average due to tannins acting as preservatives, but still present. Higher on average, as sulfites are used to protect against oxidation. None
Sugar Varies, but many are dry. Varies, can be high in sweeter varieties. None

How to Mitigate a Wine Hangover

Here are some practical steps to help minimize the morning-after effects:

  • Stay Hydrated: Drink water between glasses of wine. This is the single most important preventative measure against dehydration.
  • Eat Food: Never drink on an empty stomach. Eating a meal beforehand, particularly one with fats and protein, can slow alcohol absorption.
  • Pace Yourself: Slowing down the pace of your drinking gives your liver more time to process the alcohol and its byproducts.
  • Know Your Limits: Be mindful of how much you are drinking and what your personal limits are.
  • Choose Lighter Options: If you are particularly sensitive to hangovers, switching from red wine to a low-congener option like white wine or a clear spirit may help.
  • Consider Natural Wines: While not a guarantee, some natural wines with fewer additives may be gentler on your system, though they can still contain high levels of histamine.

Conclusion

The reputation of the wine hangover is well-earned, stemming from a perfect storm of chemical compounds and physiological effects. From the high concentration of congeners and histamines in red wine to the universally dehydrating nature of alcohol, several factors contribute to a more severe experience. While total avoidance is the only sure way to prevent a hangover, understanding the specific components in your drink can empower you to make more informed choices. By staying hydrated, eating, and pacing yourself, you can minimize the morning-after effects and continue to enjoy wine responsibly.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, not all wines cause equally bad hangovers. The severity often depends on the wine's composition, with darker, higher-congener reds typically leading to worse symptoms than lighter, lower-congener whites.

While often blamed, sulfites are not the main cause of headaches for most people. A true sulfite sensitivity is relatively rare, with symptoms usually manifesting as respiratory issues or skin rashes rather than headaches.

The 'red wine headache' is a specific phenomenon often attributed to compounds like histamines, tyramine, and tannins, which can cause blood vessel dilation and trigger headaches, even after consuming a small amount of wine.

Yes, drinking plenty of water is one of the most effective preventative measures. Since alcohol is a diuretic, staying hydrated counteracts dehydration, a primary cause of hangover headaches and fatigue.

Congeners are chemical byproducts of fermentation that are more difficult for the body to process than ethanol. This extra metabolic burden, particularly from compounds like methanol and acetaldehyde, can worsen hangover symptoms.

Eating food before or while drinking slows the absorption of alcohol into your system. This allows your liver more time to process the alcohol and its byproducts, resulting in a less severe hangover.

Not necessarily, but some older wines might contain higher levels of tannins and other compounds from oak aging. Inexpensive wines sometimes contain more additives or added sugar, which could contribute to a worse hangover.

Lighter-colored wines, such as white wine or rosé, and dry champagne are generally better choices if you are prone to hangovers, as they typically contain fewer congeners and histamines.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.