Which Gluten-Free Pasta Is the Best?

According to a 2018 study, gluten-free pasta can have a higher saturated fat and salt content than traditional pasta, which makes choosing a high-quality, nutritious option even more important. With so many brands and varieties available, from corn and rice blends to lentil and chickpea options, it can be a challenge to find the one that best suits your taste, texture preferences, and dietary goals. This guide breaks down the contenders to help you make an informed decision.

Quick Summary

This guide compares popular gluten-free pasta brands based on ingredients, texture, flavor, and cooking performance. Expert tips ensure perfect results, whether you prefer a classic taste or a higher-protein option for your pasta dishes.

Key Points

• Corn/Rice blends offer a classic texture: Barilla and Ronzoni use corn and rice to closely mimic traditional pasta, though they can harden once cooled.

• Legume pasta boosts nutrition: Banza (chickpea) and Tolerant (lentil) provide more protein and fiber but have a distinct, earthy flavor.

• Jovial's brown rice pasta is versatile: Praised for its excellent texture, this pasta holds up well in both hot dishes and cold pasta salads.

• Cooking technique is crucial: For best results, use plenty of salted water, stir frequently, and serve immediately to prevent stickiness or hardening.

• Fresh pasta offers a different experience: Fresh options from brands like Taste Republic provide a buttery, soft texture that is an excellent alternative to dried pasta.

• Brand choice depends on priority: The 'best' pasta depends on whether you prioritize classic texture, nutritional benefits, versatility, or a fresh-cooked feel.

Understanding the Different Types of Gluten-Free Pasta

Gluten-free pasta is no longer a niche product, with a wide array of options now lining grocery store shelves. The primary ingredient heavily influences the pasta's final taste and texture. Here’s a breakdown of the most common types and their characteristics:

• Rice-Based Pasta: Typically made from brown or white rice flour, this type offers a neutral flavor profile that doesn't overpower sauces. Brown rice pasta, like Jovial's, is praised for its texture and variety of shapes. However, some rice pastas can become mushy if overcooked, and some older brands were criticized for a slimy texture.
• Corn and Rice Blends: Many brands, including Barilla and Ronzoni, use a corn and rice flour blend to mimic the taste and texture of traditional pasta more closely. These options cook up with a firm texture and are less likely to become gooey. However, they can harden quickly after cooling, which makes them less ideal for pasta salads.
• Legume-Based Pasta: Brands like Banza (chickpea) and Tolerant (lentil) offer higher protein and fiber content than grain-based alternatives. The flavor can be more distinct and earthy, which works well with robust sauces. Texture can vary, and some, like Banza, require careful timing to avoid sliminess. These are great for adding a nutritional boost to your meal.
• Multi-Grain and Quinoa Blends: Some brands, such as Ancient Harvest, combine quinoa with rice and corn for a pasta with good structure and a thicker texture. This blend also boosts the nutritional profile with added protein and fiber from the quinoa.
• Fresh Pasta (Almond Flour): Brands like Cappello's offer refrigerated or frozen almond flour pasta that, when cooked, has a soft, melt-in-your-mouth quality similar to fresh wheat pasta. This grain-free, paleo-friendly option is often richer and has a subtle nutty flavor.

Expert Cooking Tips for Perfect Gluten-Free Pasta

Getting the ideal texture from gluten-free pasta can be challenging, but following these steps will help you achieve perfect results every time:

1. Use Plenty of Water and Salt: Cook gluten-free pasta in a large, generously salted pot of rapidly boiling water. This prevents the pasta from sticking together and adds flavor.
2. Stir Frequently: Unlike traditional pasta, gluten-free versions are more prone to sticking. Stir the pasta often, especially in the first few minutes of cooking, to keep the strands separate.
3. Monitor the Cooking Time: Gluten-free pasta can go from al dente to mushy very quickly. Begin testing for doneness about 1-2 minutes before the package recommends. Aim for a firm, al dente texture.
4. Transfer Directly to Sauce: For the best results, use tongs to move the cooked pasta directly from the pot to your warm sauce. This helps the sauce cling better and prevents the pasta from hardening as it cools.
5. Save the Pasta Water: Reserve a scoop of the starchy cooking water. Adding a splash to your sauce can help create a rich, velvety texture and better coat the noodles.
6. Rinse Legume Pastas: For some high-protein, legume-based pastas like Banza, rinsing after cooking can reduce the slimy texture that sometimes occurs.
7. Serve Immediately: Cooked gluten-free pasta tends to become firm and dry as it cools. Serve it hot and enjoy it right away for the best flavor and texture.

Comparison Table of Popular Gluten-Free Pastas

Feature	Jovial (Brown Rice)	Banza (Chickpea)	Barilla (Corn/Rice)	Taste Republic (Fresh)
Key Ingredients	Organic Brown Rice Flour, Water	Chickpea Flour, Pea Starch, Tapioca	Corn Flour, Rice Flour	Brown Rice Flour, Tapioca Starch, Potato Starch
Texture	Great, firm, and elastic. Resists becoming slimy.	Firm, toothsome, can be slightly grainy if not cooked carefully.	Mild, tender, closely mimics traditional wheat pasta.	Buttery, smooth, and impressively bouncy.
Flavor Profile	Neutral and classic, a perfect canvas for any sauce.	Earthy and nutty, pairs best with robust or spicy sauces.	Very mild, almost undetectable difference from standard pasta.	Rich and fresh, perfect for soaking up delicate or rich sauces.
Nutritional Perks	Organic, simple ingredients.	High in protein and fiber.	Certified gluten-free, widely available.	Fresh, quick-cooking, excellent texture.
Best For	Almost any dish, especially when a neutral flavor is desired. Excellent for pasta salads.	Adding a protein boost to your meal. Great for mac and cheese.	Everyday weeknight meals and a mild, traditional taste.	Quick meals and dishes where the pasta's fresh quality shines.
Potential Downside	Can be pricier than other dried options.	Can turn slimy if not rinsed and cooked properly.	Hardens quickly after cooling.	Shorter shelf life and requires refrigeration or freezing.

How to choose the best gluten-free pasta

The best gluten-free pasta ultimately depends on your priorities:

• For classic texture and taste: Barilla's corn/rice blend offers a widely available and reliable option that closely resembles traditional pasta, though it's best eaten hot. For a superior, all-around classic experience, many recommend Italian brand Garofalo.
• For maximum protein: Banza's chickpea pasta is a standout for boosting your protein and fiber intake, making it a more filling and nutrient-dense choice.
• For best versatility (hot or cold): Jovial's organic brown rice pasta is a top contender, praised for its great texture that holds up well, even when chilled in pasta salads.
• For a fresh pasta experience: Taste Republic is known for its delicious fresh pastas, including fusilli and ravioli, which offer a soft, buttery chew similar to fresh wheat pasta.

Conclusion

The ideal gluten-free pasta is a matter of personal preference, with different types excelling in various categories. While corn and rice blends like Barilla offer the closest approximation to traditional pasta, legume-based options such as Banza provide a significant nutritional upgrade. For a truly excellent texture that holds up well in a variety of dishes, brown rice pasta from brands like Jovial is consistently recommended. Exploring different brands and cooking techniques will help you find the best fit for your culinary needs. The key is to embrace the unique characteristics of these alternative pastas and serve them fresh for the most delicious experience.

Visit Food & Wine for more gluten-free pasta reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

Does gluten-free pasta taste the same as regular pasta?

While modern gluten-free pasta has significantly improved, it doesn't taste exactly the same as regular pasta. The taste and texture vary widely depending on the primary ingredients used, with corn/rice blends offering a flavor closest to traditional pasta.

Why does my gluten-free pasta get slimy or mushy?

Gluten-free pasta can become slimy or mushy if it is overcooked or not stirred properly during the cooking process. Using a large pot of water, cooking for the minimum recommended time, and stirring frequently can prevent this.

Can I use gluten-free pasta for cold pasta salads?

Yes, but some types of gluten-free pasta perform better than others. Rice-based pastas, like those from Jovial and Tinkyada, tend to maintain a better texture when cooled, whereas corn and rice blends can become hard.

Is gluten-free pasta healthier than regular pasta?

Not necessarily. While some legume-based gluten-free pastas offer more protein and fiber, others made from refined starches may be nutritionally similar or even higher in saturated fat and salt than regular pasta. It's important to read the nutrition labels.

How should I store leftover gluten-free pasta?

Cooked gluten-free pasta should be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days. It may dry out and harden slightly, so a small amount of water can be added when reheating.

What's the best gluten-free pasta for mac and cheese?

For mac and cheese, Banza's cavatappi or Jovial's elbows are great options because their sturdy texture holds up well to a rich cheese sauce. The high protein in chickpea pasta also adds a filling element.

Can I freeze homemade gluten-free pasta?

Yes, homemade gluten-free pasta can be frozen. Arrange the pasta pieces on a baking sheet and freeze until solid, then transfer to a freezer-safe bag or container for longer storage.