Which is better for you, butter or bacon fat? A nutritional face-off

In a 2023 survey, 88% of American households regularly purchase butter, while a significant portion also save rendered bacon fat for cooking, highlighting their shared popularity. With both being animal-based fats, the question remains: which is better for you, butter or bacon fat?.

Quick Summary

A nutritional analysis reveals subtle differences between butter and bacon fat regarding their saturated fat, monounsaturated fat, and micronutrient content. Each offers unique culinary advantages and health considerations, but moderation is key for both.

Key Points

• Fatty Acid Profile: Bacon fat contains more 'heart-healthy' monounsaturated fats than butter, which is higher in saturated fats.

• Vitamins: Butter, especially from grass-fed cows, is a notable source of fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, E, and K2, unlike bacon fat which has minimal micronutrient content.

• Sodium Content: Unsalted butter has very little sodium, while bacon fat contains residual sodium from the cured bacon.

• Cooking Temperature: Butter has a lower smoke point than bacon fat, making bacon fat slightly more suitable for moderate-heat cooking, though clarified butter (ghee) is best for high heat.

• Flavor vs. Nutrition: The choice depends on your culinary goals. Butter offers a creamy richness, while bacon fat provides a potent, smoky flavor, but both are calorically dense and best used in moderation.

For centuries, cooks have relied on animal fats to enrich the flavor of their food. Today, with increased awareness of nutrition, many are questioning the health implications of these traditional ingredients. In the contest of butter versus bacon fat, the answer isn’t as simple as good versus evil. The healthfulness of each depends heavily on its composition, how it's produced, and how it is used in cooking.

The nutritional breakdown: Butter vs. bacon fat

At a glance, butter and bacon fat appear quite similar: solid at room temperature and rich in flavor. However, their nutritional profiles show key distinctions.

Butter's composition

As a dairy product, butter is churned from milk or cream and is primarily composed of milk fat, water, and milk solids.

• High in saturated fat, constituting around 52% of its fat content.
• Rich source of fat-soluble vitamins, notably Vitamin A, D, E, and K2.
• Contains beneficial short-chain fatty acids like butyric acid, which has been linked to anti-inflammatory effects.
• Comes in salted or unsalted varieties, with sodium content varying widely.
• The nutrient profile, particularly levels of beneficial compounds like conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), can be significantly higher in butter from grass-fed cows.

Bacon fat's composition

Bacon fat, or rendered lard, is the fat released from pork belly during cooking. Unlike the consistent product of butter, the composition of bacon fat can vary based on the pig's diet and processing methods.

• Higher in monounsaturated fats (around 50%), including oleic acid, the same fat found in olive oil.
• Contains a significant amount of saturated fat (around 40%).
• Minimal vitamin or mineral content, with some traces of choline and vitamin D.
• The fat itself contains relatively low sodium, but when added during cooking, it brings the residual salt from the cured bacon.
• Unlike margarine from a past era, bacon fat does not contain artificial trans fats.

Flavor profile and culinary uses

Beyond nutrition, the choice between these two fats often comes down to their distinct flavor and cooking characteristics.

Flavor and versatility

• Butter: Offers a rich, creamy flavor that works well in both sweet and savory applications. It's a key ingredient in baking for its texture and taste, and perfect for sautéing vegetables where a nutty, delicate flavor is desired.
• Bacon Fat: Provides a robust, smoky, and salty flavor that can enhance many savory dishes. It's a favorite for Southern-style cooking, seasoning vegetables, frying eggs, or making gravies.

Cooking temperature

• Butter: With a low smoke point of around 302°F (150°C), butter can burn easily and is best suited for low to medium-heat cooking or baking. Clarified butter or ghee, which has a higher smoke point, is better for higher-heat applications.
• Bacon Fat: Has a slightly higher smoke point of around 325°F (163°C), making it suitable for moderate sautéing and roasting. Like butter, it is not ideal for high-heat frying, which can cause the fat to oxidize and smoke.

Comparison Table: Butter vs. Bacon Fat (per tablespoon)

Feature	Butter (Salted)	Bacon Fat
Calories	~102 kcal	~116 kcal
Total Fat	~12g	~13g
Saturated Fat	~7.3g (60%)	~5g (40%)
Monounsaturated Fat	~3g (25%)	~6g (50%)
Polyunsaturated Fat	~0.4g (3%)	~1g (8%)
Sodium	~91mg	~19mg (residual)
Vitamins	High in A, D, E, K2	Trace amounts
Flavor Profile	Rich, creamy	Smoky, salty, savory
Smoke Point	Low (~302°F)	Moderate (~325°F)
Source	Dairy (milk/cream)	Pork (cured belly)

The verdict: Which is better for you?

The answer is complex and depends on your overall dietary context. There is no single winner. Here’s a summary of the pros and cons for each.

Arguments for butter:

• Micronutrient Density: Contains significant amounts of fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K2), which are largely absent in bacon fat.
• Butyric Acid: Provides butyric acid, a short-chain fatty acid linked to potential gut health benefits.
• Less Processed: As a minimally processed dairy product, it avoids the nitrates and nitrites sometimes used in curing bacon.
• Grass-fed benefits: Opting for grass-fed butter can increase its content of beneficial compounds like CLA and omega-3s.

Arguments for bacon fat:

• Lower Saturated Fat: Surprisingly, bacon fat has a more favorable fatty acid ratio, with a higher proportion of monounsaturated fats compared to butter's higher saturated fat content.
• Flavor Boost: An exceptional and cost-effective way to add deep, smoky flavor to many savory dishes.
• Natural Source: A natural animal fat that contains no trans fats, unlike some older-style margarines.
• Dairy-Free: A great alternative for those who are dairy-free or lactose intolerant.

Conclusion: Moderation is the ultimate decider

Ultimately, neither butter nor bacon fat can be considered a 'health food' to be consumed in large quantities. Both are calorie-dense fats and should be used sparingly as part of a balanced diet. Your overall dietary pattern, not the occasional pat of butter or spoonful of bacon fat, will have the greatest impact on your health. For delicate flavor and vitamins, grass-fed butter is a solid choice. For a smoky, savory boost in moderation, rendered bacon fat is a culinary asset.

Frequently asked questions

What are monounsaturated fats and why are they good?

Monounsaturated fats are a type of healthy fat, largely composed of oleic acid, which is known to reduce inflammation and cholesterol levels. Bacon fat is surprisingly rich in this type of fat.

Is it safe to store bacon fat?

Yes, it is safe to store rendered and strained bacon fat. To prevent spoilage, it should be kept in a covered glass jar in the refrigerator, where it can last for several months.

Can I use bacon fat for baking?

Yes, bacon fat can be used as a substitute for butter in savory baked goods like biscuits or cornbread to add a smoky flavor. For sweet recipes, butter remains the better choice due to its creamy taste.

Does butter contain any vitamins?

Yes, butter is a good source of fat-soluble vitamins, including Vitamin A, D, E, and especially K2, which is more prevalent in grass-fed varieties.

What is the smoke point of butter vs. bacon fat?

Butter has a low smoke point of about 302°F (150°C), while bacon fat is slightly higher at 325°F (163°C), making both suitable for low to moderate heat cooking.

How does unsalted butter compare to bacon fat?

Unsalted butter has a negligible sodium content (around 2mg per tbsp) compared to bacon fat's residual sodium (around 19mg per tbsp), making it the better choice for those monitoring their salt intake.

Which fat has less saturated fat?

Bacon fat contains less saturated fat per tablespoon than butter. Bacon fat is approximately 40% saturated fat, while butter is closer to 60% saturated fat.

Citations

• Why bacon grease is gold (and the best ways to use it). familysavvy.com.
• What to Do with Bacon Grease. bensabaconlovers.com.
• Butter 101: Nutrition Facts and Health Benefits - Healthline. healthline.com.
• Butter Nutrition Facts & Benefits - U.S. Dairy. usdairy.com.
• Why bacon grease is gold (and the best ways to use it). familysavvy.com.
• Uses for Bacon Grease: A Home Cook's Guide to Bacon Fat. discover.grasslandbeef.com.
• How to Make Bacon Fat - Simply Recipes. simplyrecipes.com.
• Is Bacon Fat Any Worse For You Than Oil? - Delish. delish.com.
• Butter: Are There Health Benefits? - WebMD. webmd.com.
• Is butter good or bad for health? - Hunimed. hunimed.eu.
• Butter vs. Margarine: Which Is Healthier? - Healthline. healthline.com.
• Saving, Storing, and Reusing Bacon Grease - Southern Bite. southernbite.com.
• Is Bacon Healthy? Health Benefits, Drawbacks, and Delicious ... tofubud.com.
• Which is worse for you: bacon fat or butter? : r/nutrition - Reddit. reddit.com.
• Why bacon grease is gold (and the best ways to use it). - Family Savvy. familysavvy.com.
• Is Bacon Fat Any Worse For You Than Oil? - Delish. delish.com.
• Bacon Grease Nutrition Facts - Eat This Much. eatthismuch.com.
• Calories in Butter - Nutritionix. nutritionix.com.
• Butter, salted, 1 tbsp - Nutrition Facts - University Hospitals. uhhospitals.org.
• What are some uses for bacon grease during cooking? - Quora. quora.com.
• Is Bacon Healthy? Health Benefits, Drawbacks, and Delicious ... tofubud.com.
• Which is worse for you: bacon fat or butter? : r/nutrition - Reddit. reddit.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which fat is healthier, butter or bacon fat?

Neither is definitively healthier than the other; both are calorie-dense animal fats best used in moderation. Bacon fat contains more monounsaturated fat, while butter is richer in vitamins.

Can I use bacon fat instead of butter in recipes?

Yes, for savory dishes, bacon fat can be a great substitute for butter, adding a distinctive smoky flavor. For sweet baking, however, butter is the preferred choice for its creamy taste profile.

What is the difference between saturated and monounsaturated fats in these products?

Saturated fats, like those dominant in butter, are solid at room temperature. Monounsaturated fats, which are more plentiful in bacon fat, are typically liquid and often considered healthier for their anti-inflammatory properties.

Is bacon fat high in sodium?

While the fat itself is not high in sodium, it retains salt from the curing process of bacon. The total sodium content depends on the specific bacon used, but it is generally higher than unsalted butter.

How should I store bacon fat for later use?

To store bacon fat safely, strain it through a coffee filter or cheesecloth to remove food particles. Then, place it in a glass jar with a tight lid and refrigerate it, where it will solidify and keep for months.

Is it true that modern margarine is healthier than butter?

Recent studies suggest that modern margarine, made from healthy plant-based oils and free of trans fats, may be a healthier option than butter, especially for heart health. However, butter is less processed.

How can I incorporate butter and bacon fat into a healthy diet?

The key is moderation. Use them as flavor enhancers rather than primary cooking oils. A small amount can add significant flavor to vegetables, eggs, or sauces without compromising a balanced diet.