Skip to content

Which Jersey Mike's Bread Is Healthiest?

4 min read

According to nutrition experts, choosing a whole grain option is almost always the better choice when it comes to sandwiches. For Jersey Mike's customers, this raises the question: which Jersey Mike's bread is healthiest? The answer involves looking beyond just calories and comparing fiber, protein, and sodium content across the menu options.

Quick Summary

A nutritional breakdown reveals that Jersey Mike's wheat bread is the healthiest traditional bread option due to its higher fiber content. However, the 'Sub in a Tub'—ordering your sub contents as a salad—is the overall healthiest choice, eliminating bread carbs and calories completely. The article details calorie, fiber, and sodium comparisons for all bread types.

Key Points

  • Healthiest Traditional Bread: For a standard sub, the Wheat bread is the best choice because it offers the highest fiber content and slightly less sodium compared to other bread options.

  • Overall Healthiest Choice: The 'Sub in a Tub' is the absolute healthiest option, completely eliminating bread carbs and calories for a low-carb, high-protein meal.

  • Highest Calorie/Sodium Bread: The Rosemary Parmesan bread, while flavorful, is the highest in calories and sodium among the regular-sized bread options.

  • Protein and Fiber Powerhouse: Jersey Mike's Wheat bread provides a good source of protein and fiber, promoting satiety and supporting digestive health.

  • Control Your Add-ins: A "Sub in a Tub" gives you full control over ingredients. Opt for lean meats and vinegar-based dressings to maximize the health benefits.

  • Calorie and Carb Conscious: The gluten-free bread offers a lower-carb count, but the 'Sub in a Tub' remains the lowest-carb option available.

In This Article

Navigating a sandwich shop menu with health in mind can be a challenge. When you're at Jersey Mike's, the bread is the foundation of your meal, and understanding its nutritional impact is key to making a healthier choice. This guide will provide a detailed comparison of Jersey Mike's bread options to help you decide which one best fits your dietary goals.

The Healthiest Traditional Bread Option: Wheat

For most people seeking a standard sub, the regular Wheat bread is the clear winner for a healthier choice. While the calorie count is comparable to the White bread, the key difference lies in the fiber content. The Wheat bread offers significantly more fiber, which is crucial for digestive health and helps you feel full longer.

  • Higher Fiber: With 4 grams of dietary fiber in a regular-sized roll, the wheat bread aids digestion and promotes satiety.
  • Comparable Calories: At 290 calories per regular-sized roll, it won't drastically change your total meal calorie count compared to the white bread, which also clocks in at 290 calories.
  • Slightly Less Sodium: The regular wheat bread has 640mg of sodium, a bit less than the 670mg found in the white bread roll.

The Overall Healthiest Choice: Sub in a Tub

For those on low-carb, keto, or calorie-restricted diets, the healthiest option at Jersey Mike's isn't bread at all. The popular "Sub in a Tub" takes all the delicious sub ingredients and serves them in a bowl, transforming the sandwich into a robust salad. This choice completely eliminates the carbohydrates and calories from the bread, making it a powerful tool for weight management.

  • Zero Bread Carbs: By eliminating the bread, you cut out a major source of carbohydrates and calories.
  • High Protein, Low-Calorie Potential: With a lean meat and vegetable base, you can craft a filling meal high in protein and low in overall calories.
  • Control Your Add-ins: A 'Sub in a Tub' allows for complete control over your ingredients. Opt for a leaner protein and a vinegar-based dressing over creamy, higher-calorie sauces to maximize health benefits.

Understanding Other Bread Options

While wheat is the best standard choice, it's helpful to know how the other breads stack up. Both the White and Rosemary Parmesan options have their own nutritional profiles that may not align with healthier eating goals.

White Bread

Jersey Mike's classic White bread is made fresh daily, but offers less nutritional value than its wheat counterpart. It contains only 2 grams of fiber per regular roll and slightly more sodium. For sustained energy and digestive health, this is the least favorable option.

Rosemary Parmesan Bread

The Rosemary Parmesan bread, while flavorful, is higher in calories, fat, and sodium compared to both the wheat and white rolls. A regular roll contains 310 calories, 3g of fat (including 2g saturated fat), and 720mg of sodium.

Gluten-Free Bread

Jersey Mike's also offers a gluten-free bread option. However, its nutritional information varies, with some sources listing a regular roll at 140 calories, while others indicate higher values when combined with sub ingredients. It's crucial to check the most current nutritional info if this is a concern.

Nutritional Comparison Table (Regular Sub Roll)

Nutrient Wheat Bread White Bread Rosemary Parmesan Bread Wildflours Gluten-Free Bread Sub in a Tub (No Bread)
Calories 290 290 310 140 ~300-450+ (varies by sub)
Total Carbs 59g 58g 58g 22g ~10-15g (varies by sub)
Fiber 4g 2g 2g 3g ~1-5g (varies by sub)
Sodium 640mg 670mg 720mg 520mg ~600-1900mg+ (varies by sub)

Note: Nutritional information is based on estimates for a regular size sub roll. The exact numbers can vary depending on location and specific ingredients. "Sub in a Tub" nutrition will vary widely based on fillings and sauces.

How to Build the Healthiest Sub

Choosing the right bread is just one part of the equation. For a truly healthy meal, consider these additional tips:

  1. Opt for lean protein. Select healthier, less-processed meats like turkey breast, roast beef, or chicken instead of high-fat Italian meats.
  2. Load up on veggies. Pile on fresh, crunchy vegetables like lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and bell peppers to boost vitamins and fiber.
  3. Use light, oil-based dressing. Ask for the red wine vinegar and olive oil blend (Mike's Way) but request it be applied lightly, or get it on the side to control the portion. Avoid heavy, creamy dressings like mayonnaise.
  4. Consider a smaller size. The Regular size is plenty for most, and choosing it over a Giant will naturally reduce calories, carbs, and sodium.

Conclusion

While Jersey Mike's Wheat bread is the healthiest standard bread choice due to its higher fiber and slightly lower sodium content, the undisputed healthiest option is the "Sub in a Tub." By eliminating the bread altogether, you can create a low-carb, high-protein meal packed with fresh vegetables. Whichever option you choose, prioritizing lean protein and mindful dressing portions is key to building a nutritious and satisfying meal at Jersey Mike's.

Additional Considerations for a Healthy Meal

Don't forget to consider beverages. Water is always the best option. Avoiding soda or sugary drinks will further reduce calorie and sugar intake, helping you stay on track with your health goals. Remember, the ultimate healthiness of your meal depends on all the choices you make, not just the bread.

American Heart Association - Choosing a Healthy Diet

Frequently Asked Questions

Not necessarily. While the gluten-free bread has a lower carbohydrate count than the wheat bread, the wheat option contains more fiber, which is beneficial for digestive health and satiety. The overall nutritional profile of your meal will depend heavily on your fillings and dressings, so compare all factors.

A 'Sub in a Tub' is Jersey Mike's term for ordering your sub's ingredients served in a bowl, without the bread. It's a popular low-carb and gluten-free option that allows you to enjoy the fresh meats and vegetables in a salad format.

To reduce calories, you can make several adjustments. Choose the Regular or Mini size over the Giant, opt for lean meats like turkey, pile on fresh vegetables, and order a 'Sub in a Tub' to eliminate bread calories entirely.

The regular Wheat bread has the most fiber among the standard bread options, providing 4 grams per roll compared to the 2 grams found in both the White and Rosemary Parmesan bread.

No. While eliminating the bread reduces some sodium, the primary source of sodium in many subs comes from the deli meats and cheese. To lower sodium, choose a sub with a lower-sodium meat option like roast beef and consider omitting the cheese.

The Rosemary Parmesan bread is not as healthy as the wheat option. It has more calories, total fat, and sodium per regular roll than both the white and wheat breads, making it a less optimal choice for those watching their intake.

For a healthier sub, a light drizzle of the red wine vinegar and olive oil blend ('Mike's Way') is a good choice. You can ask for it on the side to better control the amount. Avoid heavy, creamy dressings like mayonnaise to keep calories and fat low.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.