Skip to content

Why Is Breast Milk So Good for Adults? Separating Fact from Fiction

3 min read

Historically, breast milk has been used as a folk remedy for various ailments, but experts doubt a healthy adult would benefit much from consuming it. This raises a critical question for many: Why is breast milk so good for adults, and is there any scientific truth to this claim?

Quick Summary

Despite popular wellness trends and anecdotal reports, there is no solid scientific evidence proving significant health benefits from consuming breast milk for a healthy adult. It poses serious health risks, particularly if sourced from unpasteurized or unregulated channels, and is not an effective muscle-building supplement.

Key Points

  • No Proven Benefit: For a healthy adult, there is no solid scientific evidence proving significant health benefits from consuming breast milk.

  • High-Risk Consumption: Purchasing unregulated breast milk online is highly dangerous due to the risk of bacterial contamination and infectious diseases like HIV and hepatitis.

  • Ineffective for Bodybuilding: Breast milk has a lower protein content than cow's milk and is not an effective supplement for building muscle mass.

  • Unique for Infants: Breast milk is specifically formulated for infants, containing antibodies and growth factors that are mostly destroyed by an adult's mature digestive system.

  • Better Nutritional Sources: Safer and more appropriate alternatives exist for adults seeking nutritional benefits, such as cow's milk, whey protein, and a balanced diet.

  • Component-Level Research: While preliminary research on isolated breast milk components like HMOs shows promise, these findings do not justify the consumption of whole breast milk by adults.

In This Article

The Science of Breast Milk for Infants

Breast milk is often called 'liquid gold' for a reason: it is a dynamic, living fluid uniquely tailored to the specific needs of a human infant. Its composition changes not only over the course of a single feeding but also throughout the lactation period, adapting perfectly to the growing baby. It contains a specific balance of proteins like lactoferrin and sIgA for immune support, HMOs to feed beneficial gut bacteria, growth factors for development, and essential fatty acids for neurological growth.

Debunking Adult "Superfood" Claims

While breast milk is perfectly designed for infants, adult physiology is vastly different, limiting potential benefits and making many claims unscientific. Adult stomach acidity neutralizes many immune factors in breast milk. It is not effective for muscle building due to lower protein and higher sugar content compared to cow's milk. Many reported benefits are anecdotal and likely placebo effects, and the difficulty and danger of obtaining milk from unverified sources make it impractical and risky.

The Significant Health Risks of Consuming Unregulated Breast Milk

One major danger of the adult breast milk trend is the unregulated online market. Milk from these sources is not screened or pasteurized and can transmit serious diseases. Studies have found high levels of bacterial contamination. As a bodily fluid, it can transmit HIV, Hepatitis B and C, syphilis, and cytomegalovirus. Contaminants like pesticides and BPA can also be present.

Promising Research: Components vs. Whole Milk

Research into breast milk's components shows promise for future therapies, distinct from drinking whole milk. Isolated HMOs are being studied for potential adult gut health and immune benefits. A component called HAMLET has shown the ability to kill cancer cells in lab settings, but this has not been shown to be effective in humans by drinking breast milk.

Breast Milk vs. Cow's Milk: A Nutritional Comparison

For adults seeking nutritional benefits from milk, cow's milk or fortified plant-based milk offers a safer, more appropriate, and more complete profile.

Nutrient (per 100g) Mature Human Milk Cow's Milk (approx.) Adult Nutritional Relevance
Protein 0.8-1.4g 3-4g Cow's milk has higher protein content, better for adult muscle synthesis.
Lactose 6.7-7.8g 4-5g Human milk is higher in lactose, a baby's main energy source; adults need less and can develop intolerance.
Whey:Casein Ratio 60:40 20:80 Human milk has a higher whey ratio, making it easier for infants to digest. Adults can handle the higher casein in cow's milk.
Calcium 20-25mg 120mg Cow's milk is a superior source of calcium, crucial for adult bone health.
Oligosaccharides Present Absent (in natural form) Unique to human milk and primarily beneficial for an infant's developing gut.
Immune Factors High Low Immune factors in human milk are mostly neutralized by an adult's digestive system.

Conclusion

While breast milk is optimal for infants, the idea that it benefits adults is a dangerous misconception. There is no scientific evidence of significant nutritional or immune benefits for healthy adults. Consuming unregulated breast milk poses substantial risks of infectious diseases and contamination. For adults, a balanced diet and safe supplements are better options. Excess breast milk should be donated to regulated milk banks.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, the practice has existed historically as a folk remedy for various ailments, with recent interest fueled by anecdotal online reports and wellness trends. However, there is still no scientific evidence to support its purported health benefits for adults.

No, this is a myth. Breast milk contains less protein than cow's milk and is not an efficient or safe way to build muscle. Effective and safe protein sources are widely available and much more economical.

Breast milk purchased from unregulated online sources poses serious risks, including contamination with harmful bacteria and transmission of infectious diseases such as HIV and hepatitis.

An adult's mature digestive system, particularly its higher stomach acidity, is designed to break down many of the protective immune factors and antibodies found in breast milk. A baby's developing gut, however, is better able to absorb them.

No, claims that breast milk can cure cancer in adults are not supported by solid clinical research. While a component called HAMLET has shown potential in laboratory settings, this does not translate to effective treatment by drinking breast milk.

The only relatively safe way to consume breast milk is from a known, trusted partner. Milk from a human milk bank is pasteurized and screened, but it is intended for vulnerable infants and adults do not typically have access to it for general consumption.

For adults, safer and more appropriate alternatives include a balanced diet of whole foods, cow's milk or fortified plant-based milk, and reputable supplements like whey protein for muscle building.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.