Understanding Gel Types: Traditional vs. Isotonic
Before deciding whether to mix your gel with water, it's crucial to understand the two main types of energy gels available: traditional gels and isotonic gels. The key difference lies in their osmolality, or concentration relative to your body fluids.
Traditional Energy Gels
- Composition: These are thick, concentrated sources of carbohydrates (often maltodextrin and fructose) designed to deliver a high energy dose in a compact form.
- Hydration Requirement: Because of their high concentration, your body must pull water from its own stores to dilute and digest them. Failing to do so can lead to stomach upset, cramps, and even dehydration.
- Mixing Practice: It is highly recommended to consume these gels with a few sips of plain water to facilitate faster absorption and prevent digestive issues. Mixing them into a bottle is an excellent way to pre-dilute them.
Isotonic Energy Gels
- Composition: Isotonic gels are pre-mixed with water and electrolytes, giving them a thinner, more fluid consistency.
- Hydration Requirement: These are formulated to have a similar concentration to your body's fluids, meaning they can be consumed without immediate additional water.
- Mixing Practice: Mixing isotonic gels with water is not necessary, as it dilutes their intended composition. However, it's still essential to continue hydrating with water during your run, as the gel alone does not provide sufficient fluid for overall hydration.
Benefits of Mixing Running Gels with Water
For many runners, especially those with sensitive stomachs, mixing traditional gels with water offers several key advantages during long-distance efforts.
- Reduced Gastrointestinal Distress: Consuming a highly concentrated gel can cause a fluid shift in your stomach, leading to bloating, nausea, and cramping. Pre-diluting the gel helps your stomach process the carbohydrates more smoothly.
- Easier to Consume: Squeezing a thick, sticky gel packet and then chasing it with water can be a hassle, especially during intense running. Mixing multiple gels into a single soft flask allows for easy, controlled sips of a more palatable consistency.
- Consistent Energy Delivery: By sipping on a pre-mixed gel solution, you can maintain a steadier intake of carbohydrates rather than experiencing the quick spike and crash that can sometimes occur with concentrated gels.
- Trash Reduction: For ultra-runners or those concerned with waste, mixing multiple gels into one reusable flask eliminates the need for multiple gel packets during a race.
How to Mix Running Gels with Water
Successfully mixing gels requires a little practice to find the right ratio and method that works for you. Start with a ratio of one gel packet per 8-12 ounces of water and adjust based on your tolerance.
Here is a simple mixing process:
- Gather your supplies: your preferred traditional energy gels, a reusable soft flask or water bottle, and hot or room-temperature water.
- Add the gels to the flask. Using hot water first can help thicker gels dissolve more easily.
- Add a small amount of water to the flask and shake vigorously to break up any clumps. A hand blender can also be used for a perfectly smooth consistency.
- Fill the rest of the flask with the desired amount of water and shake again until fully incorporated.
- Test the mixture on training runs to ensure it agrees with your stomach and provides the energy you need. Note your preferred concentration.
Comparison Table: Mixing Methods
| Feature | Direct Gel with Water Chase | Pre-mixed Gel in a Bottle | Isotonic Gel (No Mix) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Convenience | Requires carrying gels and water separately; can be messy. | Very convenient; one bottle contains all your fuel and water. | The most convenient; no mixing or separate water required at consumption. |
| Digestion | Can cause GI distress if not enough water is consumed immediately. | Smoother on the stomach due to pre-dilution. | Gentle on the stomach; formulated for easy absorption. |
| Waste | Creates multiple used gel packets. | Reduces trash to a single reusable flask. | Creates one used packet per gel. |
| Energy Density | High; get a concentrated carbohydrate dose quickly. | Lower; energy is spread out over more liquid volume. | Lower; contains less carbohydrate per volume than traditional gels. |
| Best For | Runners comfortable with the taste and texture of gels who don't have stomach issues. | Runners with sensitive stomachs or those who find thick gels unappealing. | All runners, especially during hotter weather when hydration is a priority. |
Considerations and Precautions
While mixing gels is a great strategy, there are important factors to keep in mind.
- Do not mix gels with sports drinks. Combining concentrated gel with another carbohydrate-rich sports drink can lead to an overload of simple sugars, causing significant gastrointestinal upset.
- Trial and error is key. The best way to know if mixing gels will work for you is to test it during training runs, not on race day. Experiment with different ratios and gel brands.
- Hydration is still critical. A diluted gel bottle is a fueling solution, not a complete hydration solution. You will still need to consume plain water separately, especially during long runs or hot weather.
- Choose the right gel. Some gels, like Maurten's hydrogel, have a very specific formulation that should not be altered. Always read the manufacturer's instructions.
Conclusion
For runners using traditional, hypertonic energy gels, mixing them with water is not only permissible but a highly effective strategy for preventing stomach issues and ensuring steady, hassle-free fueling. By pre-diluting gels into a soft flask, you can make concentrated fuel much easier to digest and consume on the move. However, this approach is unnecessary for isotonic gels, which are already pre-mixed. Regardless of your method, it is crucial to practice your fueling strategy during training and remember that a diluted gel is not a substitute for proper hydration with plain water. Find the method that works best for your stomach and race plan through careful experimentation.
Learn more about fueling for endurance sports from Crank Sports.