Did Kellogg's Say Breakfast Is the Most Important Meal?

In 1917, the popular phrase “breakfast is the most important meal of the day” first appeared as a Kellogg's marketing slogan to sell more cereal. For decades, this advertising ingenuity reshaped American eating habits, leading many to believe that skipping breakfast was a serious health mistake.

Quick Summary

The popular belief that breakfast is the most important meal stems from early 20th-century marketing by cereal companies like Kellogg's, not medical consensus. Dr. John Harvey Kellogg's early health philosophies and later marketing efforts by his brother W.K. Kellogg established this idea to sell products.

Key Points

• Kellogg's marketing: The popular phrase "breakfast is the most important meal of the day" was primarily a marketing slogan used by the Kellogg Company to promote cereal sales.

• John Harvey Kellogg's role: The idea originated with Dr. John Harvey Kellogg's health philosophies, which advocated for a bland, vegetarian diet at his sanitarium.

• Will Keith Kellogg's marketing genius: Dr. Kellogg's brother, Will, commercialized and marketed the cereal on a mass scale, strategically using advertising to frame it as essential for a healthy lifestyle.

• Modern perspective on breakfast: Current nutritional science emphasizes that the quality of one's total diet is more important than any single meal, challenging the old marketing claim.

• Cultural impact: The enduring nature of the slogan shows how powerful marketing can be in shaping long-held cultural beliefs and dietary habits.

The Roots of a Cereal Empire

The story of this famous slogan traces back to the late 19th century and the health-focused Battle Creek Sanitarium in Michigan. This institution was run by Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, a physician and Seventh-day Adventist, who believed a plain, grain-based diet was vital for good health and moral purity. In his quest to find more digestible and healthful food for his patients, Kellogg and his brother Will Keith Kellogg accidentally invented flaked cereal.

The initial invention was part of a larger wellness crusade. Dr. Kellogg promoted a vegetarian diet, exercise, and other health practices to his patients. However, it was his brother, Will, who saw the immense commercial potential beyond the sanitarium walls. The two brothers famously feuded over adding sugar to the original recipe—a move that went against Dr. Kellogg's strict principles but was key to Will's business strategy. This sibling rivalry culminated in Will breaking away to form his own company, the Battle Creek Toasted Corn Flake Company, which eventually became the Kellogg Company.

Marketing a Meal, Not Just a Cereal

With his own company, Will Keith Kellogg became a marketing pioneer. He strategically used advertising to create a cultural truth around the importance of breakfast, promoting cereal as the ideal modern, healthy, and convenient morning meal. By aligning his product with emerging nutritional science and framing a light, grain-based breakfast as essential for well-being, he wasn't just selling cereal; he was selling a behavior.

• Targeting Health Concerns: Early campaigns targeted public interest in health and hygiene, associating Kellogg's cereals with better digestion and nutrition.
• Creating a Lifestyle: Ads featured aspirational imagery of serene, energetic families gathered around the breakfast table, selling a lifestyle that middle-class families wanted to emulate.
• Appealing to Authority: Kellogg's referenced nutritional studies, some funded by cereal companies, to lend authority to the breakfast message.

The phrase took hold in the public consciousness, becoming so deeply ingrained that it felt like an undisputed medical fact rather than a carefully crafted advertisement. By the 1950s, breakfast cereal was a staple in American households, and the idea of breakfast's importance was appearing in school curricula and nutrition guides. This was a classic example of marketing transforming a product into a cultural ritual.

Modern Nutritional Perspective: Is Breakfast Truly the Most Important?

Decades later, the question of breakfast's importance has been re-evaluated by modern nutritional science. Many health experts now agree that while a nutritious breakfast can be beneficial, what and when you eat throughout the entire day is more significant. Skipping breakfast is not inherently bad for everyone, and a person's nutritional needs and preferences can vary greatly.

Aspect	Cereal-Era Marketing Perspective	Modern Nutritional Perspective
Priority	Breakfast is the single most vital meal, essential for all.	All meals contribute to daily nutritional needs; timing can be flexible.
Effect	Skipping breakfast leads to fatigue and poor focus.	Skipping breakfast is an individual choice; it may affect some people differently.
Benefits	Provides energy and boosts metabolism for the day.	Can provide energy, but overall diet quality is what truly impacts metabolism and energy levels.
Focus	Cereal was promoted as the ideal, healthy breakfast choice.	Quality of the meal is key; a healthy breakfast includes protein, fiber, and healthy fats, not just cereal.

This shift in understanding reveals how a highly successful marketing strategy reshaped dietary habits for a century. The focus has moved from the 'what' and 'when' of breakfast to the overall quality and balance of one's total daily food intake.

Conclusion: The Power of a Slogan

The answer to the question, "Did Kellogg's say breakfast is the most important meal?" is a definitive yes, but with a crucial context: it was a marketing claim, not a medical directive. The genius of Will Keith Kellogg's strategy was in framing a simple product as a crucial part of a healthy, productive lifestyle. This single slogan, repeated over decades, profoundly impacted public behavior and cemented Kellogg's place in the American cultural zeitgeist. Today, while the company still benefits from this legacy, modern consumers have a more nuanced and personal understanding of nutrition, recognizing that what you eat throughout the day ultimately matters most for your health and well-being. For a deeper dive into the history of American food culture, see Breakfast: A History by Heather Arndt Anderson.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Who originally came up with the phrase 'breakfast is the most important meal of the day'?

While the idea is rooted in Dr. John Harvey Kellogg's health philosophies, the specific phrase was popularized as a marketing slogan by the Kellogg Company in the early 20th century.

Was the idea medically supported at the time?

The idea was promoted by cereal companies that referenced emerging nutritional science, sometimes supported by the industry itself, to align their products with health and wellness.

Why did the Kellogg brothers have a falling out?

The brothers' rift began when Will Keith Kellogg wanted to add sugar to the cereal to make it more appealing to the public, a concept his puritanical brother, Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, strongly opposed.

Is breakfast still considered the most important meal by modern nutritionists?

No, modern nutritional science suggests that a person's overall diet quality is more important than prioritizing any single meal, and individual needs and preferences should be considered.

How did Kellogg's market cereal to create a cultural norm?

Kellogg's used a multi-faceted marketing strategy that included nostalgic emotional storytelling, aspirational imagery of healthy families, and associating their product with productivity and energy.

Did other companies also promote this idea?

Yes, other cereal and food companies, including Post, adopted similar marketing tactics to capitalize on the growing health-consciousness and the popularity of ready-to-eat breakfast foods.

Did Kellogg's also invent other foods?

Yes, Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, in his capacity at the sanitarium, also developed other food products like peanut butter and various meat substitutes.