Skip to content

How to Make Jersey Mike's Healthy: Your Guide to Smarter Ordering

4 min read

According to MUSC Health, converting a regular Turkey and Provolone sub into a 'Sub in a Tub' can save over 200 calories. When you know how to make Jersey Mike's healthy, you can enjoy a satisfying meal without derailing your nutritional goals.

Quick Summary

This guide provides practical strategies for customizing your order, including switching to 'Sub in a Tub,' choosing lean proteins, adding healthy vegetables, and managing high-calorie condiments.

Key Points

  • Choose the "Sub in a Tub": Order any sub as a bowl to eliminate the bread, significantly cutting carbs and calories.

  • Select Lean Proteins: Opt for turkey, roast beef, ham, or grilled chicken over higher-fat Italian meats.

  • Customize Your Condiments: Ask for vinegar and spices instead of the olive oil blend, and skip the mayonnaise to reduce calories.

  • Load Up on Veggies: Maximize your meal's volume and nutritional value by adding extra lettuce, tomatoes, and peppers.

  • Control Portion Size: Pick a mini or regular sub instead of a giant to manage your overall calorie intake effectively.

  • Leverage Flavorful Toppings: Add calorie-light options like banana peppers, jalapeños, and pepper relish for a flavor boost.

  • Modify Hot Subs: Opt for hot subs like the Chicken Philly in a bowl to enjoy grilled chicken and vegetables with fewer calories.

In This Article

Master the 'Sub in a Tub' for a Low-Carb Experience

One of the most effective ways to make your Jersey Mike's meal healthier is to embrace the "Sub in a Tub" option. Instead of a bread roll, all the fresh fillings and toppings are served in a bowl, transforming any sub into a satisfying, low-carb salad. This is an excellent choice for anyone managing their carbohydrate intake, following a keto diet, or simply aiming to reduce their overall calorie count. For example, a #7 Turkey and Provolone can be ordered "in a tub" with extra turkey, banana peppers, and pepper relish for a flavor-packed meal that is low in carbohydrates and high in protein. You can do this with any sub on the menu, including hot items like a Chicken Philly.

Choose Lean Proteins and Mindful Meats

Your protein choice is a key factor in controlling the fat and sodium content of your meal. Prioritize lean meats over processed, fatty alternatives.

  • Lean Choices: Opt for freshly sliced turkey breast, roast beef, grilled chicken, or ham. These provide a high-protein base with less saturated fat and fewer calories than their counterparts.
  • Limit Italian Meats: Salami, pepperoni, and cappacuolo are delicious but higher in saturated fat and sodium. For a healthier Italian-style option, consider a regular-sized Italian sub in a tub with minimal high-fat meats.
  • Hot Sub Hacks: For a hot sub, the Mike's Chicken Philly or Portabella Chicken Cheesesteak are better options than the traditional steak. For the Mike's Chicken Philly Bowl (#16), adding extra chicken and veggies creates a nutrient-dense and high-protein meal.

Build Your Healthy Creation: Toppings and Condiments

The condiments and toppings are where many extra calories hide. Making smart choices here can significantly impact your meal's health profile. A great technique is to order your meal "Mike's Way" but with some modifications to reduce calories.

  • The Juices: The traditional olive oil blend, while a source of healthy fats, adds calories quickly. To save calories, ask for just the red wine vinegar and spices, or order the oil on the side to control your portion.
  • Vegetable Power: Load up on all the fresh veggies you want to boost fiber and add volume. A heavy dose of lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and bell peppers will make you feel fuller without extra calories.
  • Flavor Boosts: Use low-calorie flavor boosters to compensate for less oil. Banana peppers, jalapeños, and pepper relish add a zesty kick. Ask for extra oregano and salt and pepper to season generously.
  • Cheese and Mayo: Reduce or skip the cheese and mayonnaise entirely to cut down on fat and calories. Many find that with enough vegetables and a dash of red wine vinegar, they don't miss the extra cheese or mayo.

Side Dishes and Portion Control

Making healthy choices doesn't stop at the main dish. Opting for a smaller portion size and choosing sensible sides are also crucial strategies.

  • Portion Size: Instead of the giant size, choose a mini or regular sub. If you get a regular, you can still pack it with extra veggies to make it more filling.
  • Side Swap: Trade the bag of chips and sugary drinks for water or unsweetened iced tea. This eliminates unnecessary calories and hydrates you effectively. Consider pairing your lighter sub or bowl with a side salad if you are still hungry, or a piece of fruit if you bring it from home.

Comparison: Unhealthy vs. Healthy Order

Feature Typical High-Calorie Order Healthier, Customized Order
Sub Choice #13 The Original Italian, Giant Size #7 Turkey and Provolone, Regular Size or Sub in a Tub
Bread White Bread Whole Wheat Bread or No Bread ('Sub in a Tub')
Protein Salami, Prosciuttini, Capo Extra Lean Turkey
Toppings "The Juice" (Oil & Vinegar), Mayonnaise Red Wine Vinegar, Oregano, Extra Veggies, Banana Peppers, Pepper Relish
Sides & Drinks Chips and Soda Water or Unsweetened Tea, Baked Chips (optional)
Estimated Calories ~1000-1500+ ~300-500

Create a Satisfying Meal with Flavorful Add-ins

  • Spices: The simple addition of oregano, salt, and pepper enhances the natural flavors of the ingredients. Ask for it "Mike's Way" and just tell them to hold the oil.
  • Pickles: Sliced dill pickles or kosher pickles offer a crunchy, briny, low-calorie topping that can replace fattier condiments.
  • Mustard: For a sharp, tangy kick, ask for a bit of spicy brown mustard to use as a condiment instead of mayo.
  • Hot Peppers: Banana peppers, jalapeños, and the signature hot chopped pepper relish provide a spicy burst of flavor for very few calories.
  • Extra Veggies: Don't be shy about asking for extra lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. This adds volume, fiber, and nutrients to your meal.

The Final Word: Sustainable Health at Jersey Mike's

Achieving a healthier meal at Jersey Mike's is completely manageable by focusing on a few key areas. The Sub in a Tub is a game-changer for reducing calories and carbs, while selecting leaner proteins and customizing condiments allows for significant nutritional improvements. Remember that Jersey Mike's commitment to fresh, customizable ingredients gives you full control over what you eat. By being a savvy and mindful customer, you can turn a fast-food trip into a fulfilling, diet-friendly choice. For official nutritional information, you can always check the Jersey Mike's website for specifics on calories, sodium, and more. This makes it easier to track your macros and stay on track with your health goals, even while eating on the go.

For more specific nutritional information and menu details, you can visit the Jersey Mike's official website.

Frequently Asked Questions

A "Sub in a Tub" is the low-carb and gluten-free version of any sub on the menu, served without bread. All the ingredients, including meat, cheese, and toppings, are chopped and served in a bowl.

The leanest meat options at Jersey Mike's include turkey, roast beef, ham, and grilled chicken. These are lower in saturated fat and sodium compared to Italian-style cured meats like salami and pepperoni.

Yes, you can order any sub as a 'Sub in a Tub,' including hot subs like the cheesesteaks. This allows you to enjoy the grilled meat, onions, peppers, and cheese without the bread.

To reduce calories on a "Mike's Way" sub, simply ask for no olive oil blend and no mayonnaise. The red wine vinegar and spices provide a lot of flavor without adding significant calories.

Instead of mayo and heavy oil, you can use red wine vinegar, spicy brown mustard, and the signature hot chopped pepper relish. Loading up on extra vegetables also adds flavor and texture.

While packed with vegetables, the standard veggie sub can be surprisingly high in calories and sodium due to the generous amount of cheese. A healthier option is the Portabella Chicken Cheesesteak or a custom-built veggie tub with minimal cheese.

For a healthier meal, it's best to skip the chips and cookies. Stick with water or unsweetened iced tea to drink, and fill up on extra vegetables in your tub.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.