Skip to content

Is Eating Out Really Unhealthy? A Guide to Making Smart Choices

5 min read

According to a study in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, frequent consumption of meals away from home is associated with an increased risk of early death. But is eating out really unhealthy, or does it all depend on what you order and how often?

Quick Summary

Restaurant meals are often higher in calories, sodium, and unhealthy fats than food prepared at home. Strategic planning and informed choices can help mitigate the associated health risks.

Key Points

  • Hidden Ingredients: Restaurant meals often contain excessive amounts of hidden sodium, sugar, and fat to enhance flavor, which you cannot control.

  • Portion Distortion: Larger-than-necessary restaurant portions encourage overeating and can contribute to weight gain over time.

  • Healthier Swaps: It is possible to eat healthily by opting for grilled or steamed dishes, asking for sauces on the side, and substituting vegetables for fried sides.

  • Home Cooking is Key: Preparing meals at home provides superior control over ingredients, cooking methods, and portion sizes, which is fundamental for long-term health.

  • Smart Planning: Checking a restaurant's menu and nutrition information online before you go helps make informed decisions and reduces the temptation to order unhealthily.

  • Balance is Crucial: While frequent dining out can be unhealthy, occasional restaurant meals for social and experiential benefits can be part of a balanced lifestyle.

In This Article

The Health Impacts of Frequent Dining Out

The convenience and social pleasure of eating out can come with significant health trade-offs, especially when it becomes a regular habit. Studies have consistently shown that restaurant and fast-food meals tend to be higher in calories, sodium, sugar, and unhealthy saturated and trans fats compared to meals cooked at home. This nutritional disparity is one of the primary reasons for the potential health risks associated with frequent dining out, including weight gain, heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and even mental health issues like anxiety and depression.

The Lack of Control Over Your Meal

When you eat out, you surrender control over key aspects of your food. You don't know the exact quality or freshness of the ingredients, the cooking methods used, or the amount of salt, oil, and sugar added for flavor enhancement. Restaurants often rely on pre-prepared ingredients, which can contain chemical additives and preservatives to extend shelf life. You also have no insight into the kitchen's sanitation practices, which carries a risk of foodborne illness. At home, you control every variable, ensuring your food is as clean, fresh, and nutritious as possible.

The Issue with Portion Distortion

Modern restaurants, particularly in the US, have normalized excessively large portion sizes. This phenomenon, known as portion distortion, trains our brains and bodies to expect and consume more food than is necessary. A study cited by Business Insider found that individuals who dine out consume an average of 200 more calories than those who eat at home. These oversized portions can easily lead to weight gain over time, and finishing a large plate can become a psychological imperative even if you're already full.

Comparison Table: Home Cooking vs. Eating Out

Feature Home Cooking Eating Out
Nutritional Control High. You choose the quality and quantity of all ingredients. Low. Rely on the restaurant's ingredient choices and preparation methods.
Cost Typically lower per meal, especially with bulk shopping. Higher, as you pay for ingredients, labor, and overhead.
Portion Size Easily controlled and adjusted to individual needs. Often oversized, encouraging overconsumption.
Added Ingredients Minimal. You decide how much salt, sugar, and fat to add. Substantially higher, with a focus on flavor over health.
Freshness High. You can select fresh produce and ingredients. Variable. Restaurants may use pre-prepared or frozen foods.
Dietary Flexibility High. Easy to accommodate allergies and preferences. Limited. Relies on the menu options and kitchen's willingness to modify.

Strategies for Healthier Dining Out

While frequent restaurant meals pose risks, dining out on occasion doesn't have to sabotage your health goals. The key is making informed and strategic choices.

Master the Menu Before You Go

Planning ahead is one of the most effective strategies for healthy dining. Look up the restaurant's menu online before you arrive. This allows you to review options calmly, without the pressure of a time-sensitive decision or the temptation of an enticing but unhealthy dish. Many chain restaurants with 20 or more locations are required to provide calorie counts and extensive nutritional information on their websites.

Smart Ordering: Language and Customization

Don't be afraid to communicate with your server or chef about your meal. Ask about preparation methods and request modifications.

  • Request lean cooking styles: Choose options that are baked, broiled, grilled, roasted, poached, or steamed, rather than fried or sautéed in excess oil.
  • Ask for sauces and dressings on the side: This gives you complete control over how much you add.
  • Substitute wisely: Swap out unhealthy sides like french fries for a salad, steamed vegetables, or fresh fruit.
  • Decode the menu: Look for keywords that signal a healthier option, such as 'light,' 'fresh,' 'fit,' or 'garden fresh'.

Conquering Portion Sizes

Combating oversized restaurant portions is crucial for preventing overeating. You can take control in several ways:

  • Share an entrée: Split a main dish with a dining companion.
  • Ask for a half-portion: Inquire if smaller or lunch-sized portions are available.
  • Box it up early: Before you even start eating, ask your server to pack up half of your meal in a to-go container.
  • Order from the appetizer menu: Choosing a heartier appetizer as your main course can provide a more appropriate portion.

The Inevitable Trade-offs: When is Eating Out Worth it?

Eating out isn't just about nutrition; it’s a social and cultural experience. It provides a break from the routine of cooking, offers a chance to try new cuisines, and can be a way to connect with friends and family. The psychological and social benefits can be a valid part of a balanced lifestyle. The key lies in finding a balance between the convenience of dining out and the nutritional control of cooking at home. One meal won't ruin your progress, and enjoying a 'splurge' every once in a while is perfectly acceptable. The problem arises when dining out becomes the default, rather than the exception.

The Powerful Alternative: The Benefits of Home Cooking

Cooking at home empowers you with control, nutrition, and cost savings. By preparing your own meals, you know exactly what ingredients are being used and how they're prepared, allowing you to limit unhealthy additives and focus on whole, fresh foods. This control is especially vital for people with dietary restrictions or specific health goals. Researchers at Johns Hopkins found that those who cooked at home more frequently consumed healthier diets and relied less on processed or frozen foods.

Financial and Mental Wellness Rewards

Beyond nutrition, cooking at home offers significant financial benefits. It is almost always cheaper than dining out, with average monthly savings adding up considerably. Cooking can also be a relaxing and therapeutic activity, offering a creative outlet and a way to de-stress after a long day. Family meals prepared and enjoyed at home have been linked to improved mental well-being and stronger family bonds. A balanced lifestyle incorporates both the mindful enjoyment of dining out and the health-focused benefits of home cooking.

Finding Your Balance

Ultimately, whether eating out is "unhealthy" depends on how you approach it. Frequent, mindless dining is often detrimental, but with mindful choices and strategic planning, it can fit into a healthy lifestyle. By reserving eating out for special occasions and focusing on wholesome, home-cooked meals most of the time, you can reap the benefits of both worlds. The guidance is clear: enjoy the occasional restaurant experience, but treat home cooking as the foundation for your overall health and well-being. A good rule of thumb is to prioritize vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins, whether at home or in a restaurant.

  • Choose wisely: Scan the menu for grilled, baked, or steamed options instead of fried or creamy dishes.
  • Prioritize produce: Ask for extra vegetables and make salads a key part of your meal.
  • Control the sauce: Order salad dressing, gravies, and other sauces on the side.
  • Stay hydrated: Drink water or unsweetened beverages instead of sugary sodas.
  • Snack strategically: Have a small, healthy snack before you go to prevent over-ordering when you're overly hungry.

For more specific dietary tips, resources from trusted organizations like the American Heart Association can be a valuable tool: Healthy Eating When Dining Out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Not necessarily. While most fast-food is processed and unhealthy, many chains now offer healthier options like salads, grilled chicken, or customized bowls. The key is to choose wisely and avoid fried or supersized meals.

The biggest risk is the consistently high intake of calories, unhealthy fats, and sodium, which can lead to chronic conditions like obesity, heart disease, and diabetes. The lack of control over ingredients is a major contributing factor.

Look for menu items that are grilled, broiled, baked, or steamed. Steer clear of items described as fried, battered, crispy, creamy, or smothered in sauce. Ask your server about preparation methods.

Yes, studies have found a correlation between frequent dining out and increased risks of psychiatric symptoms like depression, anxiety, and stress. This is likely linked to poorer nutritional quality and higher intake of processed foods.

Yes. Focus on mindful eating, controlling your portion sizes (share, order a half-portion, or take leftovers home), and making healthier choices from the menu. It's about moderation and strategy, not total avoidance.

Yes. Beyond obvious fat, salt, and sugar, restaurant food can contain higher levels of trans fats and additives. Some studies have even linked phthalate exposure from plastic packaging to restaurant food.

The best approach is a combination of planning ahead, making smart menu selections, and actively managing your portions. Planning helps you avoid impulsive, unhealthy decisions when you're at your hungriest.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.