The Origins of the 'Cheese Dreams' Myth
The notion that cheese causes nightmares is an old one, popularized by Ebenezer Scrooge in Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol, who blamed his ghostly visions on "a crumb of cheese". This long-standing myth has been both perpetuated and debunked by modern anecdotal evidence and informal studies. For example, a 2005 study from the British Cheese Board, while not peer-reviewed, claimed no link between cheese and nightmares, even suggesting certain cheeses might induce pleasant dreams. Yet, other findings present a more nuanced picture, highlighting individual differences and specific properties of cheese.
The Potential Benefits of a Bedtime Cheese Snack
Certain compounds in cheese can actually be beneficial for sleep. As a dairy product, cheese is rich in tryptophan, an amino acid precursor to the neurotransmitters serotonin and melatonin, both essential for regulating sleep-wake cycles. The protein and calcium in cheese also play a supporting role.
How Tryptophan Aids Sleep
Tryptophan is converted by the body into serotonin, a mood regulator, which is then converted into melatonin, the primary sleep hormone. For this process to be most effective, pairing tryptophan-rich foods with a small amount of carbohydrates can be helpful.
The Role of Calcium and Protein
Cheese is a good source of calcium, which helps the brain utilize tryptophan to produce melatonin. Furthermore, the protein in cheese, particularly casein, digests slowly and provides a steady supply of energy overnight. This helps stabilize blood sugar levels and can prevent midnight awakenings caused by a dip in glucose.
The Potential Downsides and Risks
Not everyone is suited to eating cheese before bed. For sensitive individuals, this habit can lead to significant sleep disruption. The main culprits are digestive discomfort, certain stimulating compounds, and lactose intolerance.
Digestive Discomfort and Sleep Disruption
Cheese is high in fat, and the body's digestive processes slow down at night. Eating a large portion of fatty food like cheese too close to bedtime can burden the digestive system and cause indigestion, heartburn, or acid reflux. This discomfort can lead to restless, fragmented sleep, and potentially, more vivid or disturbing dreams.
The Impact of Tyramine
Aged cheeses, such as Stilton, cheddar, and Parmesan, contain high levels of tyramine, an amino acid that triggers the release of norepinephrine. Norepinephrine is a stimulating neurotransmitter that can increase alertness, heart rate, and blood pressure—the opposite of what you want before bed.
Lactose Intolerance and Nightmares
Recent research has highlighted a strong link between lactose intolerance and an increase in vivid nightmares and poor sleep quality. For individuals with a sensitivity to lactose, the sugar found in dairy, consuming cheese before bed can lead to gastrointestinal distress, gas, and pain. These physical symptoms are believed to cause sleep disturbances that increase wakefulness during REM sleep, leading to a higher chance of remembering bizarre or scary dreams.
A Comparison of Cheeses for Bedtime Snacking
| Cheese Type | Effect on Sleep | Potential Issues |
|---|---|---|
| Cottage Cheese | Good, aids sleep via tryptophan and protein. | Higher in lactose than other types, may cause issues for sensitive individuals. |
| Mozzarella | Good, rich in calcium and tryptophan. | Small portion is key; excessive amounts can cause indigestion. |
| Swiss Cheese | Good, contains both tryptophan and calcium. | High in tyramine, so moderating portion size is important. |
| Cheddar (Aged) | Mixed; contains tryptophan, but also high tyramine. | High tyramine levels can increase alertness and interfere with sleep. |
| Stilton (Blue) | Negative; may cause strange, vivid dreams. | Highest tyramine content, acting as a stimulant that disrupts REM sleep. |
| Brie/Camembert | Mixed; some reports suggest relaxing effects, others odd dreams. | Higher fat content can be difficult to digest late at night. |
Best Practices for a Bedtime Cheese Snack
If you choose to enjoy cheese before bed, following these best practices can help minimize the risk of sleep disruption:
- Mind your portion size. A small amount, such as an ounce or two, is far less likely to cause issues than a large, heavy meal.
- Time it right. Eat your snack at least two to three hours before you plan to go to sleep. This gives your body ample time to digest.
- Choose wisely. Opt for mild, low-fat cheeses like cottage cheese or mozzarella over aged, tyramine-rich varieties.
- Pair it with carbs. Pairing cheese with whole-grain crackers helps enhance tryptophan's access to the brain, supporting melatonin production.
- Listen to your body. Pay attention to how your body and sleep patterns react. If you notice a negative effect, it's best to avoid cheese at night.
Conclusion
Ultimately, whether it's okay to eat cheese before going to bed depends on your individual physiology and your cheese selection. For most people, a small, low-fat portion of cheese consumed a few hours before bedtime is perfectly fine and may even support sleep due to its tryptophan and calcium content. However, those with lactose intolerance or a sensitivity to tyramine found in aged cheeses should be more cautious, as these factors can disrupt digestion and lead to restless nights or nightmares. The key is moderation, timing, and making an informed choice that works best for your body.
For more information on the intricate relationship between diet and sleep quality, consult academic resources such as this National Institutes of Health review on dairy and sleep.