What is Natamycin?
Natamycin, also known as pimaricin (E235 in Europe), is a naturally occurring antimicrobial compound produced during the fermentation of the bacterium Streptomyces natalensis. Discovered in the 1950s, this polyene macrolide antibiotic works by binding to sterols in fungal cell membranes, effectively disrupting them and inhibiting growth. A key advantage for cheese making is that natamycin is inactive against bacteria. This allows it to prevent unwanted mold without affecting the beneficial bacteria needed for ripening and flavor.
The Role of Natamycin in Food Production
Used for decades as a food preservative, natamycin is effective at low concentrations (typically 1-10 parts per million). It prevents fungal spoilage, which significantly reduces food waste and protects consumers from harmful mold-produced mycotoxins. Its natural origin and effectiveness make it a popular choice for manufacturers seeking a 'clean label'.
The Regulatory Verdict: Is Natamycin in Food Safe?
Global food safety organizations have evaluated and approved the use of natamycin as a food additive within specific limits. For instance, the FDA allows its use in cheese up to 20 milligrams per kilogram (20 ppm) to inhibit mold and yeast. The EFSA has found no safety concerns when used at approved levels on certain cheeses, and JECFA considers its Acceptable Daily Intake satisfactory. Natamycin is usually applied as a powder mixed with an anti-caking agent to the surface of shredded cheese to inhibit mold.
Potential Concerns and Allergic Reactions
While most consumers have no issues with natamycin, a few potential concerns exist.
- Sensitivities and Allergies: A small number of individuals report mild gastrointestinal issues or other reactions after consuming products with natamycin. These sensitivities are different from the severe allergic reactions linked to higher concentration, pharmaceutical-grade natamycin used in eye drops.
- Antifungal Resistance: There is a theoretical concern about food-grade natamycin potentially contributing to antifungal resistance in the gut. However, regulatory reviews have not identified this as a significant safety issue at food-use levels.
- The 'Natural' Debate: The use of natamycin is debated by some retailers who avoid it based on their definition of 'natural', despite its microbial origin. This is generally a marketing preference rather than a food safety issue, given its regulatory approval.
Natamycin vs. Other Preservatives: A Comparison
Comparing natamycin with other preservatives helps understand its use. Here's a comparison with sorbate:
| Feature | Natamycin | Sorbate |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Natural, derived from bacteria. | Chemical, synthesized. |
| Antimicrobial Effect | Fungicidal (kills fungi). | Fungistatic (inhibits fungal growth). |
| Effect on Bacteria | No effect on bacteria, allowing bacterial ripening. | Can have some bactericidal effect. |
| Migration | Limited migration; stays on the surface due to low solubility. | Penetrates into the food product. |
| Effect on Flavor | Tasteless and odorless at low concentrations. | Can impart a bitter flavor if not used correctly. |
| Effective pH Range | Wide range (pH 3-9), suitable for many foods. | Effective primarily at acidic pH levels. |
How to Identify Natamycin on a Label
To check for natamycin, look at the ingredient list for 'natamycin' or, in Europe, 'pimaricin (E235)'. In the U.S., it's usually listed as 'natamycin'. Products specifically avoiding it may state they are preservative-free, use different methods, or have a shorter shelf life, as some retailers prefer.
The Nutritional Context and Final Verdict
From a nutritional standpoint, the minimal amount of natamycin used has little impact. It's used in trace amounts and poorly absorbed by the body. The main nutritional factors in cheese are typically its fat and sodium content.
Using natamycin involves a trade-off: extended shelf life and reduced food waste versus using a food additive. Consumers decide if the benefits of a longer, safer shelf life outweigh personal preferences regarding additives. Those with sensitivities might choose cheeses without natamycin or shred block cheese at home.
Conclusion
Global food safety agencies generally consider natamycin safe for the general population within approved limits. It is a natural antifungal effective against mold and yeast, reducing waste and preventing harmful mycotoxin formation. While rare sensitivities and potential resistance are concerns, they are minimal compared to the food safety benefits. For further scientific details, {Link: foodadditives.net https://foodadditives.net/preservatives/natamycin/} provides additional information, or consult the review from the National Institutes of Health.