Understanding the Origins: Stevia vs. Sugarcane Fermentation
To understand why sugarcane Reb M is not the same as stevia, one must first appreciate the nuance of their origins. The term "stevia" often refers to the extract from the Stevia rebaudiana plant, which contains numerous sweet compounds called steviol glycosides. The most abundant of these is Reb A, which provides intense sweetness but can have a bitter or licorice-like aftertaste.
Rebaudioside M (Reb M) is a different, much rarer steviol glycoside also found in the stevia plant. It is highly prized for its clean, sugar-like taste and lack of bitter aftertaste. However, extracting Reb M directly from the plant is extremely costly and inefficient due to its low concentration.
This is where innovative biotechnology comes in, leading to the creation of sugarcane Reb M. Instead of extracting it from the stevia leaf, companies have engineered microorganisms, typically yeast, to ferment sugarcane sugar into the exact same Reb M molecule. This process allows for efficient, large-scale, and cost-effective production of the pure, high-quality Reb M compound without relying on the limited supply from the stevia plant.
A Closer Look at the Differences
Though they share a key component, the two sources of Reb M result in distinct products. The most significant difference lies in their taste profile and manufacturing process. Traditional stevia extracts, rich in Reb A, are known for their sweet yet sometimes bitter flavor profile. Sugarcane Reb M, being a more purified product, offers a cleaner, more consistent sugar-like sweetness.
Fermentation vs. Plant Extraction
- Fermentation-based production: This method uses microorganisms to convert a sugar source, like sugarcane, into Reb M. The final product is a highly pure, zero-calorie sweetener that is bio-identical to the Reb M found in the stevia leaf but does not contain any other steviol glycosides that might affect the taste.
- Plant-based extraction: Traditional stevia extracts are made by soaking and purifying the leaves of the stevia plant. This process yields a mix of different steviol glycosides, with varying purity levels, which can influence the final flavor.
The "Natural" Debate
Consumers seeking a "natural" label for their sweeteners have sparked a debate surrounding fermented sugarcane Reb M. Some argue that since the fermentation process uses genetically engineered yeast, the resulting product should not be considered natural or non-GMO. However, many manufacturers contend that because the yeast is filtered out and the final Reb M molecule is bio-identical to the one in the stevia plant, it is a natural ingredient. The non-GMO status often depends on the sourcing of the feedstock (sugarcane or corn sugar) and local regulations, leading to varying labeling.
Comparison Table: Sugarcane Reb M vs. Stevia Extract
| Feature | Sugarcane Reb M | Stevia Extract |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Source | Fermented sugarcane via engineered yeast. | Leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana plant. |
| Sweetening Compound | Highly pure Reb M (Rebaudioside M). | A mix of steviol glycosides, predominantly Reb A. |
| Taste Profile | Very clean, round, and sugar-like with minimal to no bitter aftertaste. | Can have a slightly bitter or licorice-like aftertaste, especially at higher concentrations. |
| Manufacturing Process | Biotechnology-based fermentation. | Traditional leaf extraction and purification. |
| Cost | More cost-effective to produce on a large scale than extracting Reb M from leaves. | Cost-effective for Reb A, but expensive for high-purity Reb M. |
| Sustainability | Requires less land and water than traditional stevia farming for the same Reb M output. | Uses more agricultural resources for high-purity Reb M. |
| Consistency | Highly consistent, ensuring reliable flavor. | May have slight variations depending on the extract's glycoside profile. |
Applications in Food and Beverages
Because of its superior taste profile, Reb M is highly sought after by food and beverage manufacturers. It is particularly effective in products where taste is paramount and any off-notes from other sweeteners would be noticeable. For instance, Reb M is used in:
- Carbonated beverages
- Dairy products like yogurts and ice cream
- Baked goods
- Tabletop sweeteners
- Protein powders
Conventional stevia extracts, particularly those dominated by Reb A, are still widely used, especially in blends where their lower cost is advantageous. Manufacturers often combine different steviol glycosides or add other ingredients to mask the off-tastes associated with Reb A. This versatility allows the stevia family of sweeteners to be used across a broad range of products, catering to different taste preferences and price points.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the sweetening compound Reb M can be found in the stevia plant, sugarcane Reb M is not the same as stevia. It is a modern, bio-identical form of Reb M created through the fermentation of sugarcane. This advanced manufacturing process addresses the taste and cost limitations of extracting Reb M directly from the stevia leaf, offering a cleaner, more sugar-like taste profile for a wider range of food and beverage products. Consumers can now choose between traditional stevia extracts, with their characteristic flavor profile, or the newer fermented sugarcane Reb M, known for its consistency and clean taste. The market for natural zero-calorie sweeteners continues to evolve, providing more options than ever before for managing sugar intake without sacrificing flavor.
References
- Ritual. (2025). Meet Amyris, Our Fermented Sugarcane (Reb-M) Manufacturer. https://ritual.com/articles/ritual-reb-m
- TruLabs. (2025). What is Sugarcane Reb M?. https://trulabs.com/blogs/tru-blog/what-is-sugarcane-reb-m
- Javvy Coffee. (n.d.). What is Reb M (OnoSweet™)?. https://javvycoffee.com/support/questions/what-is-reb-m-onosweet-tm
- FoodNavigator-USA. (2017). New stevia sweetener BESTEVIA® Reb M may disrupt the sugar industry. https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/News/Promotional-features/New-stevia-sweetener-BESTEVIA-R-Reb-M-may-disrupt-the-sugar-industry/
- LinkedIn. (2024). What Is Reb M? Exploring the Stevia Compound Changing the Game. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-reb-m-exploring-stevia-compound-changing-game-nutramax--afskc
: https://ritual.com/articles/ritual-reb-m : https://trulabs.com/blogs/tru-blog/what-is-sugarcane-reb-m : https://javvycoffee.com/support/questions/what-is-reb-m-onosweet-tm : https://amyris.com/ingredient/rebm : https://pyureorganic.com/blogs/commercial-sweetener-ingredients-blog/reb-a-reb-m-reb-d-prime-stevia-commercial-sweeteners : https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/News/Promotional-features/New-stevia-sweetener-BESTEVIA-R-Reb-M-may-disrupt-the-sugar-industry/ : https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-reb-m-exploring-stevia-compound-changing-game-nutramax--afskc : https://www.steviaworld.ca/rebaudiosides : https://www.cargill.com/food-beverage/na/eversweet-faqs : https://www.amazon.com/stores/Purecane/page/171B255D-AC9E-4538-A16F-5B3DE4C21FC4 : https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-reb-m-exploring-stevia-compound-changing-game-nutramax--afskc : https://www.steviaworld.ca/rebaudiosides : https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-reb-m-exploring-stevia-compound-changing-game-nutramax--afskc
