Skip to content

What Are the Two Types of Shelf Life? A Guide to Food Safety vs. Quality

4 min read

According to the Food Standards Agency, confusion over food date labels contributes significantly to household food waste. Understanding what are the two types of shelf life is not only key to preventing unnecessary waste but is also vital for protecting consumer health from harmful bacteria. This involves recognizing the critical distinction between a 'Use By' date, which concerns safety, and a 'Best Before' date, which relates to quality.

Quick Summary

The two primary types of shelf life relate to either food safety ('Use By' date) or food quality ('Best Before' date). Factors like packaging, temperature, and product composition all heavily influence a product's lifespan and should be considered by consumers and manufacturers.

Key Points

  • Use-by vs. Best-before: The two most important types of shelf life for consumers distinguish between food safety and food quality, respectively.

  • Use-by is for Safety: Never eat food after its 'Use By' date, as it could contain harmful bacteria even if it appears and smells fine.

  • Best-before is for Quality: Food can still be safe to consume after its 'Best Before' date, though its flavor, texture, or quality may have declined.

  • Primary vs. Secondary Shelf Life: A more technical distinction exists between a product's shelf life while sealed (primary) and its often-shorter lifespan after being opened (secondary).

  • Environmental Factors are Key: The integrity of a product's shelf life depends heavily on extrinsic factors like storage temperature, humidity, and proper handling by both retailers and consumers.

  • Understanding Labels Reduces Waste: Misinterpreting date labels leads to significant food waste; knowing the difference empowers consumers to make informed decisions and reduce their environmental impact.

  • Manufacturer's Responsibility: Manufacturers determine a product's shelf life based on testing and legally mandate the correct labeling based on product characteristics and risk.

In This Article

Understanding the 'Use By' Date: A Safety Imperative

The 'Use By' date is the most critical date to observe on food packaging as it relates directly to food safety. It is mandatory for foods that are highly perishable and likely to pose an immediate health risk if consumed after the stated date. These are the kinds of foods where harmful bacteria could grow, even if the product appears fine to the naked eye and smells normal. The sniff test is not an appropriate method for assessing the safety of a product past its 'Use By' date. A product should not be eaten, cooked, or frozen after this date has passed. Examples of products with a 'Use By' date include:

  • Fresh meat and poultry
  • Pre-packaged salads and ready-to-eat sandwiches
  • Some dairy products, like pasteurized milk
  • Cured meats and fish

It is an offense for retailers to sell products past their 'Use By' date. This date is based on the manufacturer's assessment under the specified storage conditions, which is why following instructions like 'keep refrigerated' is essential for the date to be valid.

Deciphering the 'Best Before' Date: A Guide to Quality

In contrast to the 'Use By' date, the 'Best Before' date is an indicator of food quality, not safety. This date, sometimes abbreviated as BBE, suggests that the product will retain its optimum flavor, texture, aroma, and appearance up to this point. It is most commonly found on dried, tinned, and frozen foods, or other items with a longer shelf life. After the 'Best Before' date, the food is still safe to consume, but its quality might begin to decline. For example, biscuits might become stale, or spices may lose some of their potency. This is where consumer judgment, often aided by the 'sniff test,' is appropriate.

Examples of foods with a 'Best Before' date include:

  • Dried pasta and rice
  • Canned goods
  • Frozen foods like vegetables and chips
  • Biscuits, crisps, and honey

For foods with a shelf life of two years or more, such as some canned foods, a 'Best Before' date is often not required at all.

The Concept of Primary and Secondary Shelf Life

A deeper, technical distinction in the food science and manufacturing world is between primary and secondary shelf life. This recognizes that the environment changes significantly once a package is opened. Primary shelf life is the period during which a product remains in a hermetically sealed, unopened package and maintains its quality and safety. Secondary shelf life is the period after the package has been opened by the consumer. For some products, like canned sardines or certain pharmaceuticals, this secondary shelf life is drastically shorter than the primary one. A sealed jar of sauce may last for years, but once opened and refrigerated, it may only be good for a few days.

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Factors Affecting Shelf Life

Multiple factors influence a product's shelf life, categorized as either intrinsic or extrinsic. Intrinsic factors are inherent to the food product itself, including its water activity, pH level, and chemical composition. High water activity, for instance, promotes microbial growth, while higher acidity (lower pH) can inhibit it. Extrinsic factors are external conditions during manufacturing, storage, and distribution, such as temperature, humidity, and exposure to light. Even the type of packaging plays a crucial role; barrier packaging can prevent oxygen or moisture from spoiling the food.

Why Knowing the Difference Matters

Educating consumers about the meaning of these date labels has significant benefits. Firstly, it enhances public health by ensuring people do not consume potentially hazardous foods. Secondly, it helps reduce the enormous amount of food waste that occurs when perfectly safe food is discarded simply because it has passed its 'Best Before' date. By following the correct guidelines, consumers can make more informed decisions, store food appropriately, and maximize its usability, thereby promoting both safety and sustainability.

Comparison: Use-By vs. Best-Before

Feature Use-By Date Best-Before Date
Focus Food Safety Food Quality
Risks After Date Potentially unsafe; risk of food poisoning Safe, but quality may be reduced (flavor, texture)
Legal Status Illegal to sell products past this date Legal to sell products past this date (if still fit for consumption)
Food Types Highly perishable items: fresh meat, salads Long-life items: dried, canned, frozen foods
Consumer Action Do not eat, even if it looks and smells fine Use own judgment; safe to eat if sensory cues are normal

Extending Shelf Life Through Proper Handling

To ensure products last as long as intended by the manufacturer, consumers must adhere to storage instructions. This means keeping perishable items consistently refrigerated, minimizing the time they are left at room temperature during preparation, and ensuring packaging remains intact until use. For items with a long best-before date, like canned goods, keeping them in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight is best to preserve quality over time. Freezing can also be a powerful tool for extending shelf life, acting as a 'pause button' on microbial activity, but once defrosted, items have a short secondary shelf life. Food Standards Agency provides excellent guidance for UK consumers on navigating food date labels.

Conclusion: Making Informed Choices

In summary, the two main types of shelf life, as defined by date labels, are distinguished by their purpose: one for safety and one for quality. The 'Use By' date is a strict safety guideline for perishable items, while the 'Best Before' date is a recommendation for optimal quality on more stable products. By understanding and properly applying this knowledge, consumers can significantly impact their food safety practices and contribute to a reduction in food waste, making them more informed and responsible food handlers.

Frequently Asked Questions

A 'Use By' date relates to food safety and is for highly perishable foods that must be consumed by that date. A 'Best Before' date refers to the food's quality, indicating it is at its best before this date, but may still be safe to eat afterwards.

Yes, it is generally safe to eat food after its 'Best Before' date, as long as it has been stored correctly and looks, smells, and tastes normal. However, the quality, such as its flavor or texture, may have started to deteriorate.

The 'sniff test' is unreliable for foods with a 'Use By' date because harmful bacteria that cause food poisoning cannot be detected by smell or sight. The food may appear fine but still be unsafe to consume.

Primary shelf life is the duration a product remains safe and at its peak quality in its original, sealed packaging. Secondary shelf life is the period after the package has been opened, which is often much shorter due to exposure to air and other factors.

Storage conditions, such as temperature, humidity, and exposure to light, significantly affect a product's shelf life. For a product to last until its stated date, it must be stored according to the manufacturer's instructions, such as keeping it refrigerated.

Freezing food acts as a 'pause button' for spoilage bacteria, but it does not preserve quality indefinitely. The taste and texture can still be affected over time. Also, once thawed, the product must be cooked and consumed quickly.

Foods with a very long shelf life, such as some canned foods (two years or more), vinegar, and solid sugar, are often exempt from needing a 'Best Before' date. Fresh fruit and vegetables that have not been peeled or cut are also exempt.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.