What Should Not Be Eaten with Buttermilk?

According to traditional Ayurvedic wisdom, certain food combinations can disrupt digestion and create imbalances in the body. Knowing what should not be eaten with buttermilk can help prevent discomfort like bloating, gas, and indigestion, ensuring you get the most out of this nutrient-dense and probiotic-rich beverage.

Quick Summary

Several foods, including fish, certain sour fruits, and regular milk, should generally be avoided with buttermilk due to potential digestive conflict and imbalances. Proper food pairing supports better digestion and absorption of nutrients, aligning with principles of holistic health and traditional dietary practices. Paying attention to these combinations can help prevent common gastrointestinal issues.

Key Points

• Avoid Fish: Combining buttermilk with fish is discouraged, especially in traditional and Ayurvedic practices, due to a clash of 'heating' and 'cooling' energies that can disrupt digestion.

• Separate Sour Fruits: Buttermilk should not be mixed with acidic or citrus fruits like oranges or pineapples, which can cause excessive curdling, increased acidity, and discomfort.

• Do Not Mix with Milk: Never combine fresh milk and buttermilk, as this will cause rapid curdling in the stomach, leading to gas, bloating, and indigestion.

• Watch Heavy Proteins: Buttermilk is a fermented product and should not be paired with heavy proteins like meat or legumes in large quantities to avoid taxing the digestive system.

• Use Spices for Digestion: For enhanced digestion and balanced flavor, it is best to mix buttermilk with warming spices like roasted cumin, black pepper, or ginger.

• Enjoy Mango Separately: Ayurvedic principles advise against combining mangoes with milk products like buttermilk, as it is believed to hinder digestion and create toxins in the body.

Introduction to Proper Buttermilk Food Pairing

Buttermilk, known as 'takra' in Ayurveda, is a fermented dairy product celebrated for its digestive benefits. It is light, tangy, and packed with probiotics, calcium, and B vitamins. While it is a healthy drink on its own and a great addition to many meals, not all food combinations are considered equal. According to both ancient Ayurvedic principles and anecdotal modern experience, certain pairings can cause digestive stress and other issues, undermining the beverage's benefits. This guide explores which foods you should avoid eating with buttermilk for optimal digestion and wellness.

Incompatible Foods to Avoid with Buttermilk

Fish and Seafood

One of the most widely cited incompatible food combinations, particularly in Ayurvedic and some Asian cultural traditions, is fish and buttermilk.

• Reasoning: Ayurveda views fish as 'heating' in nature, while buttermilk is considered 'cooling'. The combination of these opposing energies is believed to cause a systemic imbalance, disrupting digestion. Buttermilk's fermented nature and fish's high protein content are also processed differently by the body, potentially leading to gastrointestinal discomfort, bloating, or even skin issues in sensitive individuals. While modern science lacks conclusive evidence that this pairing is inherently dangerous, the anecdotal discomfort many report and the long-held tradition suggest it is a combination best avoided, especially for those with a sensitive stomach.
• Modern Take: While scientific studies haven't proven harm, many dietitians still suggest that for those with weak digestion, pairing two different types of heavy proteins (fish and dairy) can be taxing on the system.

Sour and Citrus Fruits

Combining buttermilk with highly acidic or sour fruits is generally discouraged.

• Reasoning: Buttermilk is already acidic from its fermentation process. Adding more sour elements like oranges, lemons, or pineapple can cause it to curdle further in the stomach, potentially leading to excessive acidity, heartburn, and indigestion. This is particularly relevant for those prone to gastric issues.
• Specific Fruits to be cautious of: While some berries can be an exception, it's best to avoid citrus fruits entirely when drinking buttermilk to prevent curdling and digestive upset.

Other Dairy Products (Especially Milk)

As a fermented product, buttermilk should not be combined directly with fresh milk.

• Reasoning: Mixing fresh milk with buttermilk essentially causes the fresh milk to curdle rapidly inside your stomach. This rapid fermentation can lead to significant discomfort, including bloating, gas, and stomach cramps, as the digestive system is not meant to process this kind of internal 'fermentation tank'.

Certain Proteins and Legumes

Some dietary traditions also advise against combining buttermilk with other heavy proteins, such as large quantities of meat or certain legumes, as both require significant digestive effort.

• Reasoning: When the digestive system is processing multiple heavy proteins at once, it can become sluggish. This can result in slower digestion, fermentation, and subsequent gas and bloating. It is generally recommended to enjoy buttermilk separately or with lighter meals to aid digestion, not burden it.

Mangos (According to Ayurveda)

While the mango milkshake is a popular concoction, Ayurvedic principles caution against combining milk and sweet fruits like mango. This extends to buttermilk.

• Reasoning: Ayurveda considers mango and milk to be incompatible foods that create 'ama,' or toxins, due to digestive conflict. Mixing fruits with dairy is believed to hamper digestion, causing gas, bloating, and potential skin issues over time. For those with sensitive digestion or existing inflammatory conditions, this combination is best avoided.

Comparison Table: Buttermilk Pairings

Food Category	Compatibility with Buttermilk	Reason	Best Practices
Fish/Seafood	Incompatible	Opposing energies (heating vs. cooling); heavy proteins require different digestive enzymes, leading to bloating and indigestion.	Consume separately. Wait a few hours between eating fish and drinking buttermilk.
Sour/Citrus Fruits	Incompatible	High acidity can cause buttermilk to curdle prematurely in the stomach, increasing acid reflux and digestive upset.	Avoid combining with fruits like oranges, lemons, or pineapple. Use sweet spices instead.
Fresh Milk	Incompatible	Rapid curdling occurs in the stomach, leading to digestive discomfort, gas, and bloating.	Do not mix fresh milk and buttermilk. Consume them at different times.
Heavy Meats/Legumes	Best avoided	Combining multiple heavy proteins can tax the digestive system, slowing digestion and causing discomfort.	Enjoy buttermilk with lighter meals or on its own to aid digestion.
Mango	Incompatible (Ayurveda)	Believed to create toxins ('ama') and cause digestive conflict, leading to bloating and skin issues.	Avoid mango shakes. Enjoy mangoes as a separate meal or snack.
Spices (Cumin, Ginger)	Highly Compatible	Warming spices like roasted cumin, ginger, and black pepper are traditionally added to buttermilk to enhance digestion and balance its cooling properties.	Mix with spices to create a soothing, digestive drink like 'masala chaas'.

Conclusion

While buttermilk is a powerful and beneficial food for digestive health, pairing it correctly is essential to reap its rewards without negative side effects. Adhering to traditional wisdom, particularly from Ayurveda, can help guide your choices and prevent uncomfortable digestive symptoms. By avoiding incompatible combinations like fish, citrus fruits, and fresh milk, you can ensure that buttermilk serves its purpose as a digestive aid rather than a source of stress for your system. Listen to your body, and if a particular pairing causes you discomfort, it is wise to avoid it, regardless of whether a modern scientific study supports it. For centuries, observing such dietary rules has been the cornerstone of maintaining good health and promoting longevity.

Optional External Link

For a deeper look into the scientific understanding of food pairing and digestion, you can read more from a nutritional science perspective at The Dairy Alliance.

Always Consult a Healthcare Professional

For personalized dietary advice, especially if you have pre-existing health conditions or allergies, consult with a qualified healthcare professional or dietitian.

References

The Wellness Corner. "Foods That Don't Really Go Well With Milk. Avoid These." The Wellness Corner, February 2, 2022. Hirst, David. "What should be avoided while drinking buttermilk? Are there..." Quora, October 31, 2023. Sharma, Subhankar. "Why should one not drink milk and buttermilk together? - Quora." Quora, August 16, 2017. Times of India. "7 Foods to avoid eating with fish." Times of India, November 24, 2023. Times of India. "This is why mixing mango and milk is not a great idea." Times of India, June 5, 2025. Dr. Sushant Sud. "Buttermilk - The Divine Ayurvedic Medicine - By Dr. Sushant Sud." Lybrate, August 23, 2024. Woyic. "How Buttermilk Supports Digestive Health: Ayurvedic Insights for..." LinkedIn, August 29, 2025. The Dairy Alliance. "Cultured Dairy Foods: Why Your Fridge Should Have Buttermilk." The Dairy Alliance, August 27, 2025. Tirumala Milk Products. "10 Health Benefits of Buttermilk | Nutrition, Digestion & More." Tirumala Milk Products. Fitelo. "Can We Drink Buttermilk After Eating Fish? Yes Or No - Fitelo." Fitelo, June 5, 2024. Mr. Doctor. "The Myth Surrounding Milk Consumption After Fish." Medium, November 24, 2024.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is combining fish and buttermilk considered a bad idea?

Combining fish (considered 'heating') and buttermilk (considered 'cooling') is thought to cause an imbalance in the digestive system, leading to issues like bloating and indigestion, according to Ayurvedic principles and some cultural traditions.

Can I have buttermilk with my fruit salad?

It is generally not recommended to have buttermilk with sour or citrus fruits, as the acidity can cause the buttermilk to curdle excessively in the stomach, leading to acid reflux and digestive upset. However, combinations with less acidic fruits are sometimes tolerated.

Why shouldn't you mix fresh milk with buttermilk?

Mixing fresh milk and buttermilk is discouraged because the fermentation from the buttermilk will cause the fresh milk to curdle rapidly in your stomach, leading to bloating, gas, and discomfort.

Does mixing mango and buttermilk cause any problems?

According to Ayurveda, mixing sweet fruits like mangoes with dairy products like buttermilk is considered incompatible and can disrupt digestion, potentially causing bloating, gas, and skin issues over time.

What happens if I eat meat and then drink buttermilk?

Buttermilk should not be consumed with heavy proteins like meat, especially in large amounts, as processing two different types of heavy proteins at once can put a strain on the digestive system, causing sluggishness and discomfort.

What are some safe and beneficial food pairings with buttermilk?

Buttermilk pairs well with traditional ingredients like roasted cumin, ginger, and salt, which enhance its digestive properties and create a soothing beverage. It can also be incorporated into baked goods or used in marinades.

Is the advice about incompatible foods with buttermilk based on science?

While some advice stems from long-held anecdotal and Ayurvedic traditions, the potential for digestive discomfort from certain pairings (like combining heavy proteins or different acids) is supported by basic principles of digestion, and listening to your body's response is key.