Skip to content

What do vegans replace dairy with? A comprehensive guide

4 min read

According to a 2022 survey, the global dairy alternatives market was valued at $26.1 billion, demonstrating the huge demand for products that replace dairy. For many, the prospect of giving up milk, cheese, and yogurt can seem daunting, but today's market offers an incredible variety of plant-based options that make the switch effortless and delicious.

Quick Summary

This guide provides a detailed look at the many plant-based products used to substitute for dairy, including milks, cheeses, butters, and yogurts, highlighting their unique flavors and best uses.

Key Points

  • Variety of Plant Milks: Vegans replace dairy milk with popular options like soy, oat, almond, and coconut milk, each with unique textures and uses.

  • Nutritional Yeast for Cheese Flavor: Nutritional yeast, or 'nooch', is a key ingredient used to impart a savory, cheesy flavor to vegan sauces and toppings.

  • Nut and Starch Bases for Cheese: Many vegan cheeses, from soft spreads to hard blocks, are made from soaked nuts like cashews or almonds, with starches used for melting.

  • Vegan Butter Options: Vegan butter and margarine, made from vegetable oils like coconut and sunflower, are readily available and perform similarly to dairy butter.

  • Fortified Products for Nutrients: To ensure adequate nutrition, many plant-based dairy alternatives are fortified with key nutrients like calcium and vitamin B12.

  • Diverse Yogurt and Cream Replacements: Yogurts and creams are often made from soy, coconut, or cashews and fermented with probiotics, offering a range of flavors and thicknesses.

  • Lower Environmental Impact: Choosing plant-based dairy alternatives contributes to a lower environmental footprint, with reduced greenhouse gas emissions, land, and water use.

In This Article

Plant-Based Milk Alternatives

One of the most common dairy replacements is plant-based milk. The market has exploded with options derived from nuts, grains, and seeds, each offering a distinct flavor and texture profile. This variety allows vegans to choose the perfect milk for their coffee, cereal, baking, and cooking needs.

Common Vegan Milk Varieties

  • Soy Milk: The original plant-based milk, known for its high protein content and creamy texture. Unsweetened varieties are excellent for savory recipes, while sweetened versions are great for baking. It can be curdled with vinegar or lemon juice to create a dairy-free buttermilk.
  • Oat Milk: Loved for its natural sweetness and thick, creamy consistency, which makes it an ideal choice for lattes and coffee drinks. It is also great for baking and for using in creamy sauces. Barista-style oat milks are specifically formulated to froth well.
  • Almond Milk: A popular low-calorie option with a light, nutty flavor. It works well in smoothies, cereal, and sweet recipes. However, its lower protein content compared to dairy milk means it's not a direct nutritional substitute.
  • Coconut Milk: Available both in cartons as a beverage and in cans for cooking. The canned, full-fat version is rich and creamy, perfect for curries, soups, and making thick creams for desserts. The carton version is much thinner and better for drinking or lighter recipes.
  • Cashew Milk: Known for its rich, creamy texture and mild flavor, making it excellent for creamy sauces, coffee, and ice cream. Like almond milk, it is lower in protein but provides healthy fats.
  • Pea Milk: A newer player in the market, made from yellow field peas. It is a great source of protein, often rivaling or exceeding the protein content of dairy milk. Brands like Ripple are known for their high protein and calcium content.

Vegan Cheeses and Their Bases

Vegan cheese has evolved significantly over the years, moving beyond simple tofu-based products to a vast array of artisanal and commercial options. While the taste and texture might not be identical to dairy cheese, many options offer a satisfying alternative for different applications.

Ingredients Used for Vegan Cheeses

  • Nuts (Cashews, Almonds): Soaked and blended nuts form a creamy base for many types of vegan cheese, especially soft cheeses like cream cheese, brie, and ricotta. They can be fermented to develop more complex, tangy flavors.
  • Nutritional Yeast: Often referred to as 'nooch', these deactivated yeast flakes have a savory, cheesy, and nutty flavor. It is a staple ingredient for making vegan parmesan and cheese sauces. It is also an excellent source of vitamin B12 when fortified.
  • Starches (Tapioca, Potato): These are used to help vegan cheeses melt and create a stretchy texture similar to mozzarella. Tapioca starch, for instance, is a key ingredient in many homemade and store-bought melting vegan cheeses.
  • Soy: Tofu and soy milk can be used to create various soft cheeses, from crumbly feta to smooth cream cheese. Tofu absorbs flavors well, making it very versatile.
  • Coconut Oil: The high-fat content of coconut oil is essential for creating firm, sliceable vegan cheese blocks and for improving the melt of cheese shreds.

Vegan Butter, Yogurt, and Cream

Replacing other dairy products is also simple with modern vegan options. The market provides excellent substitutes for almost any dairy item a vegan might need.

Replacements for Common Dairy Products

  • Butter: Vegan butter is widely available in supermarkets, often made from a blend of vegetable oils such as coconut, sunflower, and olive oil. Many brands offer both block and spreadable varieties suitable for cooking, baking, and spreading on toast. Coconut oil can also be used as a butter substitute in some recipes.
  • Yogurt: Plant-based yogurts are commonly made from soy, almonds, or coconut milk, fermented with live cultures. They come in various flavors and consistencies, from thick, Greek-style yogurts to thinner, drinkable types. Recipes for homemade versions are also readily available.
  • Cream: Vegan creams and whipped toppings are often coconut-based, offering a rich and thick texture ideal for desserts and sauces. Oat milk and soy-based creams are also available, with barista blends designed not to curdle in hot drinks.

Comparison Table: Dairy vs. Vegan Alternatives

Feature Conventional Dairy Vegan Alternatives (Example: Fortified Soy/Oat) Notes
Protein Content High (8g per cup) Varies, can be comparable (7-8g per cup) Soy and pea milks are highest in protein.
Calcium High (~300mg per cup) Can be fortified to be comparable Check labels; fortification levels differ between brands.
Saturated Fat High (Whole milk: ~4.5g) Generally lower Most plant milks are lower in saturated fat.
Cholesterol Contains cholesterol Naturally cholesterol-free Plant-based options are beneficial for heart health.
Environmental Impact Higher (land, water, emissions) Significantly lower Oat and soy have particularly low environmental footprints.
Taste Profile Uniform, consistent Highly varied Tastes range from creamy and sweet to nutty and earthy.
Allergens Lactose, milk protein Nuts, soy, or gluten (in some oat milks) Options exist for common allergens like nuts and soy.

How to Choose Your Dairy Replacements

Selecting the right vegan alternative depends on your needs and how you plan to use it. For cooking and baking, consider the fat content and flavor profile. Creamy, higher-fat milks like soy or cashew are often best for richness, while a thinner milk might suffice for cereal. Fortified options are crucial for maintaining adequate nutrient intake, particularly calcium and vitamin B12. It is also worth experimenting with different brands to find your preferred taste and texture.

Conclusion

The notion that a vegan diet means a restrictive life without creamy, cheesy delights is outdated. With an ever-expanding market of plant-based options, consumers can now find high-quality, flavorful, and nutritionally varied alternatives for almost every dairy product imaginable. From milks and cheeses made from nuts, grains, and legumes to rich butters and yogurts, the world of vegan dairy replacements is diverse and exciting. By understanding the different types and how to use them, anyone can successfully and deliciously navigate a dairy-free lifestyle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Soy milk is often considered the most versatile vegan milk for both cooking and baking, due to its creamy consistency and high protein content. Unsweetened versions can be used in savory dishes, while sweetened types are good for desserts.

Many store-bought vegan cheeses designed to melt, particularly mozzarella-style shreds, use coconut oil and starches like tapioca. For homemade versions, recipes often rely on a combination of soaked cashews, nutritional yeast, and starches to achieve a stretchy texture.

Nutritional yeast is the primary ingredient used to achieve a savory, cheesy, umami flavor in many vegan dishes, from mac and cheese sauces to parmesan alternatives.

Yes, many vegan butter products are specifically formulated to be used as a 1:1 substitute for dairy butter in baking. Look for block-style vegan butters rather than spreads for best results in recipes requiring solid butter.

Vegans can get sufficient calcium by choosing plant-based milk and yogurt alternatives that are fortified with calcium and vitamin D. Other sources include tofu, leafy green vegetables, and fortified juices.

For creamy desserts and sauces, vegans use full-fat coconut cream or specific dairy-free creams made from soy or oat. Many of these products, including whipping cream alternatives, are widely available.

The healthiness varies by product. Many plant-based alternatives are lower in saturated fat and calories than full-fat dairy, and are cholesterol-free. However, nutrient profiles differ, so checking labels for fortification and added sugars is important.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.