What is the Health Star Rating and how does it work?
The Health Star Rating (HSR) system provides a visual shortcut for consumers navigating the supermarket aisles. Developed collaboratively by the Australian and New Zealand governments, public health experts, and consumer and industry groups, its purpose is to help consumers compare the nutritional content of similar packaged food products. A product's rating is displayed prominently on the front of the pack, making it a powerful tool for informed decision-making at the point of purchase.
How are Health Stars calculated?
The rating is determined using a specific algorithm that assesses both positive and 'risk' nutrients per 100g or 100mL of a product. This provides a consistent basis for comparing different foods within the same category. The calculation process involves balancing these nutrient scores to arrive at a final rating from ½ to 5 stars.
Positive nutrients and ingredients that increase a product's star rating include:
- Dietary fibre
- Protein
- Fruit, vegetable, nut, and legume (FVNL) content
Risk nutrients and components that decrease a product's star rating include:
- Energy (kilojoules)
- Saturated fat
- Sodium (salt)
- Total sugars
Limitations of the Health Star Rating system
While the HSR is a valuable tool, it has several limitations that consumers should be aware of. Understanding these can help prevent misleading assumptions about a product's overall healthiness.
- Voluntary application: The system is voluntary for manufacturers, which can lead to inconsistencies. Companies often apply the HSR to products with high ratings, while foods with low ratings are more likely to be left unrated. This selective use can hinder effective comparisons.
- Category-specific comparisons: HSRs should only be used to compare products within the same food category (e.g., comparing one breakfast cereal to another) and not across different categories (e.g., a breakfast cereal with a yoghurt). This is because the algorithm differs based on the food type.
- Doesn't evaluate whole foods or processing: The algorithm assesses individual nutrients, not the overall composition or degree of processing of the food. This can lead to anomalies where highly processed foods with fortified nutrients score higher than less-processed, natural alternatives. For instance, a processed margarine may have a higher HSR than natural butter.
- No evaluation of additives: The system does not consider the presence of additives, such as artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, in its calculation. To determine a product's 'naturalness' or additive content, consumers must still read the ingredients list.
Health Star Rating vs. Nutrition Information Panel
While the HSR offers a convenient front-of-pack summary, the Nutrition Information Panel (NIP) provides a more detailed, mandatory breakdown of a food's nutritional content. Both labels serve different but complementary purposes.
| Feature | Health Star Rating | Nutrition Information Panel (NIP) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Quick, front-of-pack nutritional comparison for similar packaged foods. | Detailed, mandatory nutrient breakdown per serving and per 100g/mL. |
| Rating Scale | Half a star to five stars, with higher stars indicating a healthier option. | No overall rating, but provides specific values for fat, protein, carbs, etc.. |
| Comparability | Designed for easy, at-a-glance comparison within a food category. | Requires more effort from the consumer to analyze and compare products. |
| Mandatory | Voluntary for manufacturers, which can lead to inconsistent application. | Mandatory on almost all packaged foods by law. |
| Calculation | Based on a complex algorithm balancing positive and risk nutrients. | Presents a factual list of nutrient quantities as per the product's formulation. |
| Information Type | A simplified, visual summary of overall nutritional profile. | A raw data table of specific nutrient content. |
Conclusion
The Health Star Rating system is a useful, quick-glance tool that helps consumers make healthier food choices when comparing similar packaged products. However, its voluntary nature and algorithm-based calculation have limitations, including inconsistent application and potential biases. While the HSR can guide you towards better choices, it should not replace general dietary advice. For a complete understanding of a food's nutritional profile, it is always best to consult the Nutrition Information Panel and ingredients list. For more comprehensive information, the official Health Star Rating website provides detailed guides for consumers and manufacturers alike.