The Foundation: Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ)
Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) is the primary body responsible for setting and administering the Food Standards Code for Australia and New Zealand. This code is the core legal document that governs the use of nutrition, health, and related claims on food labels and in advertising. The purpose of the regulations is to ensure that all claims made about food are truthful and scientifically substantiated, thereby protecting consumers from misleading or deceptive representations. FSANZ develops the regulations and, for some claims, provides pre-approval based on scientific evidence.
The Enforcement Arm: ACCC and State Agencies
While FSANZ creates the standards, it is not the sole enforcer. The actual implementation and enforcement of the Food Standards Code in Australia are carried out by a combination of federal and state-level bodies. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) plays a crucial role in preventing misleading and deceptive conduct under the broader Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The ACCC can take enforcement action against companies that breach consumer law, as was the case with H.J. Heinz over a misleading health claim. Day-to-day monitoring and compliance checks are managed by designated state and territory government agencies.
Understanding Standard 1.2.7
Standard 1.2.7 of the Food Standards Code outlines the requirements for nutrition and health claims. These are categorized into three main types:
- Nutrition Content Claims: Claims about the amount of a nutrient or substance in a food (e.g., "low in fat"). These must meet specific criteria.
- General Level Health Claims: Link a food or substance to a general health effect (e.g., "calcium is good for strong bones"). Manufacturers can use pre-approved relationships or self-substantiate claims with scientific evidence, notifying FSANZ.
- High Level Health Claims: Link a food or substance to a serious disease or its biomarker (e.g., "Diets high in calcium may reduce the risk of osteoporosis"). These require pre-market assessment and approval by FSANZ.
Foods with health claims must also meet the Nutrient Profiling Scoring Criterion (NPSC) to ensure overall nutritional quality.
The Food-Medicine Interface: FSANZ vs. TGA
Determining whether a product is a food or a medicine adds another layer to regulation. The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) regulates therapeutic goods like medicines. A product cannot be both a food and a medicine. The TGA uses the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 for classification, which can be complex depending on claims and presentation. For example, a blueberry extract capsule is more likely a medicine than whole blueberries. Claims and presentation dictate whether FSANZ (foods) or TGA (medicines) regulates the product.
The Enforcement Process in Practice
Enforcement involves several bodies:
- Complaint Submission: Concerns can be reported to state/territory health agencies or the ACCC.
- Investigation: Agencies investigate, possibly requesting substantiation from manufacturers.
- Resolution: Outcomes can range from communication with the business to warnings or court action.
- ACCC Action: The ACCC can take strong action against misleading conduct, including court proceedings and penalties.
Comparing Regulatory Bodies: FSANZ vs. ACCC
| Feature | Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) | Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Role | Sets food standards, including those for nutrition and health claims. | Enforces consumer protection laws against misleading conduct. |
| Key Regulation | Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code, Standard 1.2.7. | Australian Consumer Law (ACL). |
| Specific Focus | Determines permitted claims and conditions. | Acts when claims are misleading, regardless of specific food standards. |
| Enforcement | Develops standards enforced by state agencies, assesses high-level claims. | Investigates and takes legal action against ACL breaches. |
| Example Action | Pre-approves high-level claims and lists general-level claims. | Took H.J. Heinz to court for misleading claims. |
Conclusion
Nutrition and health claims in Australia are controlled through a multi-agency system involving FSANZ, the ACCC, and state/territory agencies. FSANZ establishes the Food Standards Code, while state authorities enforce compliance. The ACCC enforces the Australian Consumer Law, addressing misleading conduct. This layered framework ensures accountability and protects consumers from deceptive marketing. For more details, consult FSANZ's official guidance.