Demystifying Nutrition and Health Claims
Food packaging often features statements like 'low fat' or 'rich in fibre', which are examples of nutrition and health claims. Understanding the difference between these claims is vital for making informed dietary choices. Regulatory bodies such as the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulate these claims to ensure they are scientifically sound.
What are Nutrition Claims?
Nutrition claims indicate that a food has specific beneficial nutritional properties due to its composition, often related to its energy value, protein, fat, carbohydrates, vitamins, or minerals. These claims can be:
- Nutrient Content Claims: These describe the amount of a nutrient, such as 'high in fibre' which requires a minimum amount per serving, or 'low in fat' and 'sugar-free'.
- Comparative Claims: These compare nutrient levels between similar foods, such as '25% less sugar than our standard version'.
What are Health Claims?
Health claims suggest a link between a food or its components and a health benefit, requiring scientific evidence and strict regulation. Regulatory bodies categorize these claims:
- General Level Health Claims: These link a food component to a normal body function, like 'calcium for healthy bones and teeth'.
- High-Level Health Claims (or Reduction of Disease Risk Claims): These connect a food component to reducing the risk of a serious disease, such as 'Diets high in calcium may reduce the risk of osteoporosis in people 65 years and over'. These often require pre-approval.
The Key Differences Between Nutrition and Health Claims
| Feature | Nutrition Claim | Health Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Content of a nutrient or substance (e.g., 'low fat'). | Relationship between a nutrient/food and a health effect (e.g., 'calcium builds strong bones'). |
| Level of Detail | Quantitative and compositional (how much of a nutrient is present). | Relational and functional (what the nutrient does for your health). |
| Regulatory Rigor | Requires the product to meet specific threshold criteria for nutrient levels. | Requires substantiation with scientific evidence, often needing pre-approval from regulators. |
| Implicit Message | This food has a specific nutrient profile. | This food, in the context of a healthy diet, can offer a specific health benefit. |
| Example | 'High in Vitamin C' | 'Vitamin C contributes to the normal function of the immune system.' |
The Consumer's Role: Reading Beyond the Claim
Claims alone don't define a food's healthiness. A 'fat-free' product might be high in sugar or sodium. Consumers should also check the Nutrition Information Panel (NIP), ingredients list, and compare products using standardized metrics like 'per 100g'. Guidance from bodies like the FDA can help interpret serving sizes and daily values.
The Importance of Regulation
Regulation of these claims is vital for consumer protection, preventing misleading statements and ensuring claims are scientifically accurate. This promotes public health and fair competition. Products with health claims often must also mention the importance of a varied diet.
Conclusion
Understanding what are nutrition and health claims is a valuable consumer skill. Nutrition claims describe food composition, while health claims link food to health benefits. Both are regulated for accuracy. However, claims should not be the only factor in purchasing decisions. By also reviewing the Nutrition Information Panel, ingredients list, and comparative values, consumers can make informed choices about their diet.